Skip to main content

You’re not paranoid: Apps are tracking your location 24/7 and it’s totally legal

A shocking new investigation reveals that companies can track you constantly, with your phone constantly broadcasting your exact location at all times.

The New York Times published the investigation on Thursday, using a leaked dataset from one of the many location data companies that collect data from your favorite mobile apps, and the results are unsettling. The investigation, part of the Times Privacy Project series, looked at data of more than 50 billion location “pings” from the phones of more than 12 million Americans from 2016-2017. 

Recommended Videos

“You’ve probably never heard of most of the companies — and yet to anyone who has access to this data, your life is an open book. They can see the places you go every moment of the day, whom you meet with or spend the night with, where you pray, whether you visit a methadone clinic, a psychiatrist’s office or a massage parlor,” the article reads. 

According to the Times, weather, local news, and deal saver apps, along with popular software like Netflix are all used to share your location. 

Location Tracking Visualization
Image used with permission by copyright holder

“Many apps that use your location, like weather services, work perfectly well without your precise location — but collecting your location feeds a lucrative secondary business of analyzing, licensing, and transferring that information to third parties,” the Times wrote. 

In theory, the location data could be used to keep an eye on employees, stalk celebrities, find out if your spouse is cheating on you, or be sold to other companies to target specific ads to you. 

The location data information collected by these types of apps is legal to collect and sell since there is no federal privacy law, which is a cause for concern in and of itself. The companies reportedly only share this type of sensitive data with “vetted partners.” 

Stuart Thompson, one of the New York Times journalists who wrote the piece, spoke with Digital Trends Live on Thursday about the findings and the legality of collecting geolocation data.

“This piece is arguing for federal laws and Congress to look into this issue,” he said. “You can’t really blame [the companies] because they aren’t violating any laws, because the laws don’t exist.”

By tracking location data information, one could identify a person pretty quickly, in some cases, less than 30 seconds according to Thompson. For example, your commute from your home to work is unique to you and your smartphone that travels with you. 

“Really precise, longitudinal geolocation information is absolutely impossible to anonymize,” Paul Ohm, a law professor and privacy researcher at the Georgetown University Law Center, told the Times. “DNA is probably the only thing that’s harder to anonymize than precise geolocation information.”

The article goes on to name some of the companies in the location data sphere, calling out such names as Foursquare, Factual, Unacast, Teemo, and many more. 

“There are dozens of companies profiting off such data daily across the world — by collecting it directly from smartphones, creating new technology to better capture the data or creating audience profiles for targeted advertising,” the article said. 

We already know that with progress in technology comes more progress in surveillance, but the sheer scale of this data is dizzying. Luckily, there are ways to protect yourself by turning off location services on individual apps, but that might mean giving up key features, like Google Maps’ ability to detect where to go when looking for directions.

Thompson told Digital Trends has changed his smartphone habits since reporting on the data set.

“I’m sort of a nut now maybe but I turn off my locations at all times and I’m ruthless about talking to people to make sure they review their apps,” he said. “People just don’t know—they think they do, but they don’t.”

In the coming days, the Times Privacy Project will expand on how this data set has implications on national security and how tracking people’s locations could affect protestors and democracy itself.

Allison Matyus
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Allison Matyus is a general news reporter at Digital Trends. She covers any and all tech news, including issues around social…
Apple’s smart home display already sounds like a convenience victory
Nest Hub Max

Over the past few weeks, rumors of Apple developing a smart display for home control have picked up pace. The company is said to be developing two versions, and one of them might even feature a robotic arm and revive an iconic Mac’s design. 

Now, Bloomberg has shared some juicy details about how the entry-level option will look and work. The device will offer a 6-inch screen with a square-ish format flanked by sensors, including a FaceTime camera in landscape orientation. 

Read more
Trade group says EV tax incentive helps U.S. industry compete versus China
ev group support tax incentive 201 seer credit eligibility

The Zero Emission Transportation Association (ZETA), a trade group with members including the likes of Tesla, Waymo, Rivian, and Uber, is coming out in support of tax incentives for both the production and sale of electric vehicles (EVs).

Domestic manufacturers of EVs and their components, such as batteries, have received tax incentives that have driven job opportunities in states like Ohio, Kentucky, Michigan, and Georgia, the group says.

Read more
The Penguin fans think it hid a classic Batman villain in plain sight
Cristin Milioti stands behind Theo Rossi in The Penguin.

It may be a spinoff of one of the biggest comic book movies of the past few years, but The Penguin is actually pretty light on Easter eggs and deep-cut references. That said, some fans of the DC series believe they've spotted an intriguing pair of items in it that may hint at one Penguin character's real identity. Fans have specifically spotlighted a quick shot from The Penguin's fourth episode in which Sofia Falcone (Cristin Milioti) is shown standing alone in the office of her former Arkham Asylum psychiatrist, Dr. Julian Rush (Theo Rossi).

Behind Sofia, fans have noted a familiar-looking rag mask hanging on Rush's desk, as well as a glove with what looks like syringe-like fingers, two items that are famously worn in the comics by Jonathan Crane, a.k.a. Scarecrow. Like Rush, Scarecrow is a psychology expert in the comics, one who develops a hallucinogenic drug that he uses to terrorize the people of Gotham City with their worst fears. At no point in The Penguin does Rush do anything like that, but the presence of the villain's mask and glove in his office has led many to speculate about whether or not Rossi's character will turn out to be the Scarecrow of Matt Reeves' Batman universe.

Read more