Apple’s iPhone 4S lands Consumer Report blessing, still behind Android phones

By Andrew Couts Published November 8, 2011

apple-iphone-4s-white-black — Apple

Consumer Reports announced today that it recommends Apple’s new iPhone 4S, saying that the smartphone performed “very well” in its battery of tests. The trusted product review magazine, which denied a “recommend” to the iPhone 4 due to its “Antennagate” reception issues, said Apple has fixed these problems in the iPhone 4S.

“In special reception tests of the iPhone 4S that duplicated those we did on the iPhone 4, the newer phone did not display the same reception flaw, which involves a loss of signal strength when you touch a spot on the phone’s lower left side while you’re in an area with a weak signal,” writes Mike Gikas on the Consumer Reports website.

Recommended Videos

Both the GSM and CDMA version of the iPhone 4 still exhibit reception problems due to its antenna, says Gikas.

While some iPhone 4S users have experienced poor battery life — a problem Apple says is due to a flaw in iOS 5, and has promised to fix with an upcoming update — Consumer Reports observed no such battery drain, and said the handset deserves a “very good” ranking on battery life. Gikas says they plan to re-test the device once Apple releases its iOS 5 fix.

Overall, the iPhone 4S scored higher than the iPhone 4 thanks to its faster dual-core processor, upgraded 8-megapixel camera, and the all-new Siri voice-activated artificial intelligence system, which lets users search, text, email and perform a variety of other functions just by speaking naturally.

Perhaps more notable than the higher ranking of the iPhone 4S is that Apple’s handset still falls behind a number of Android devices, including the Samsung Galaxy S II and the Motorola Droid Bionic, both of which sport larger screens and have the ability to connect to 4G networks — a key feature the iPhone 4S lacks.

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…

Mobile

The iPhone 17 Pro may not have a redesigned camera after all

A close-up of the cameras on the iPhone 16 Pro.

If you've followed any of the previous iPhone 17 leaks, then you likely read that the camera is supposedly getting a redesign that makes it look more like a Pixel than an iPhone. The phone is still almost a year away, so many rumors are just hearsay with no confirmation at this point. Now, a new leak suggests that while the iPhone 17 Pro will see a change, the camera module will remain triangular.

According to tipster Setsuna Digital on Weibo, the camera won't undergo as drastic a redesign as previously believed. "My sources told me that the back has indeed changed, but the triple-camera layout is still a triangle, not the horizontal strip that is currently circulating online." The majority of leaks so far have been from different companies within the supply chain that manufacture different parts for the iPhone 17 Pro.

Mobile

Visual Intelligence has made the Camera Control on my iPhone 16 worth using

Using Visual Intelligence on an iPhone 16 Pro showing ChatGPT answer.

One of the big selling points of the iPhone 16 hardware is the Camera Control button. It’s a small physical button on the bottom right of the frame that also has some capacitive capabilities. With the initial launch of iOS 18, a single press launches your camera app of choice, and you can do half presses and sliding gestures to adjust camera settings. It’s a neat idea, but it has some flaws that prevent it from being a great shutter button.

But now we have iOS 18.2, and that brought a lot of new Apple Intelligence features to our phones, especially if you have an iPhone 16. With iOS 18.2, Apple finally added Visual Intelligence, a feature similar to Google Lens, but on iPhone.

Mobile

A new render teases the iPhone 17 Pro Max’s big redesign, and I’m torn

Leaked render of iPhone 17 Pro Max front glass and rear camera bar module.

With the iPhone 16 line, Apple made some big changes with the base models, while the iPhone 16 Pro versions looked identical to those from the past several years. But Apple appears to be making some very significant changes to the design of the iPhone 17 Pro Max — especially if these mock-up renders from a Russian YouTube channel, Wylsacom, are accurate.

The YouTube video shows that the iPhone 17 Pro Max will look nothing like its predecessors, according to the rumors that this mock-up is based on.