Skip to main content

FCC defies net-neutrality advocates, votes 3-2 to move forward on proposal

fcc and isps battle over data collection tom wheeler
FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler FCC/Flickr

Today’s FCC vote pushed forward a proposal that could effectively reshape the Internet. The plan, which was approved along party lines (Democrats- 3, Republicans-2), may allow ISPs to charge higher fees to websites for faster delivery of their content.  

The vote was a testament to the influence of FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler. Two of the five commissioners (Democrat Jessica Rosenworcel and Republican Ajit Pai) involved in the vote had earlier stated that they wanted a delay in the proceedings. This indicated that Wheeler faced a revolt in his agency. In spite of widespread condemnation of the plan, however, he was able to convince the two other Democrats in the commission, Rosenworcel and Mignon Clyburn, to vote his way. 

Recommended Videos

Rosenworcel, for her part, made it clear that she cast her vote half-heartedly. “I would have done this differently. I would have taken the time to consider the future,” she said. “I believe the process that got us to rulemaking today was flawed. I would have preferred a delay.”

Clyburn, on the other hand, said that the result of the vote will allow people to contribute their insights into the plan. “The real call to action begins after the vote today … This is your opportunity to formally make your points on the record. You have the ear of the entire FCC. The eyes of the world are on all of us,” she said. 

As it is right now, the FCC’s proposals may allow ISPs to make deals with content companies to provide Internet “fast lanes” for delivery of content. However, the agency’s proposal is seeking feedback on whether to ban what it calls “paid prioritization.”

“NPRM (Notice of Proposed Rulemaking) adopted doesn’t authorize, it asks whether paid prioritization should be banned,” the agency said in a tweet.

“Today’s vote could spell the beginning of the end of the Internet as we know it, plain and simple,” Sen. Al Franken told Digital Trends. “Because of net neutrality, the Internet has been a tremendous platform for innovation and connectivity. But the FCC has taken a woefully misguided step toward handing the Internet over to big corporations who can pay boatloads of money for preferential treatment. Anyone who values a free and open Internet should be deeply troubled by the FCC’s vote, and I plan to do everything I can to convince them that they need to change course.”

If you want to read the proposal in more detail, the FCC has released a fact sheet, which you can find here. You can also contribute comments at www.fcc.gov/comments.

Christian Brazil Bautista
Christian Brazil Bautista is an experienced journalist who has been writing about technology and music for the past decade…
Best early Black Friday deals under $100: Amazon Echo, TVs, headphones and more
The Amazon Echo Pop on a desk.

Update 11/19/24: Black Friday is still over a week away, but you can already start your shopping with the Black Friday deals under $100 that we've gathered here. There's a possibility that these affordable items get even bigger discounts when the sale officially launches, but we won't blame you if you're already tempted by today's prices.

Black Friday will start on November 29, but if you've already got the itch to shop, check out the early Black Friday deals under $100 that we've gathered here. The offers cover smart home devices, laptops, TVs, kitchen gadgets, and so much more, so if you want to start enjoying discounts without blowing your entire budget for the shopping event, take a look at our favorite bargains below.

Read more
The Galaxy A56 may get one of the S24 Ultra’s top features
A person using the Samsung Galaxy A55.

Samsung may be ready to change one of the long-standing negatives about its otherwise desirable Galaxy A5x series phones — the charging speed. For the Galaxy A55’s replacement, currently expected to be called the Galaxy A56, Samsung may introduce 45-watt charging speeds, a big increase over the current 25W charging, according to a report originating in China.

The source is an official-looking certificate from the Chinese government’s Quality Certification Centre (CQC) which is responsible for ensuring devices sold in China meet the required standards. The phone is listed as the SM-A5660, and seeing as the Galaxy A55’s model number is the SM-A556, it’s not much of a stretch to assume we’re looking at details of the unreleased Galaxy A56. Apparently, the phone’s maximum 10V/4.5A system equates to a 45W charging speed.

Read more
I used a Wear OS smartwatch for the first time, and I love it
Someone wearing an Apple Watch Ultra and Pixel Watch 3 on different wrists.

Ever since the original Apple Watch, smartwatches as a whole have really taken off. Though Apple largely dominates the market, there are still plenty of non-Apple smartwatches to choose from.

I’ve been solely an Apple Watch user for the past decade, but I’ve been trying out a Google Pixel Watch 3 for the past couple of weeks. And, honestly, I kind of love it.
A round smartwatch is so much sleeker

Read more