Skip to main content

Apple accused of pressuring labels to remove music from Spotify

Apple store logo
Image used with permission by copyright holder
As the debut of Apple’s streaming music service quickly approaches, sources close to The Verge say the company’s aggressive pursuit of content exclusivity has attracted scrutiny from regulators in the Justice Department. According to the report, Apple’s been privately pushing record labels to abandon ad-supported, free listening platforms like YouTube and Spotify that might otherwise compete with its own subscription-only service.

Apple reportedly offered to pay YouTube’s music licensing fee to Universal Music Group if the label agreed to disallow its songs on the video sharing website, and has also been actively discouraging music labels from renewing licenses for Spotify’s free tier. “All the way to Tim Cook, these guys are cutthroat,” one music industry source told The Verge.

Recommended Videos

Apple’s motivation is clear: The company’s new service, which sources say will cost $10/month with no free tier, has millions of users to gain. Spotify has around 60 million active listeners, only a quarter of which pay a subscription fee. Major music releases that are free to watch on YouTube, meanwhile, regularly rack up tens of millions of views, sometimes hundreds of millions — and even billions.

Please enable Javascript to view this content

Sources tell The Verge that Department of Justice officials have interviewed high-ranking music industry executives about Apple’s practices. Separately in Europe, the European Union’s Competition Commission is continuing a probe into Apple’s moves to harm “freemium” music services, which don’t charge a monthly fee.

This isn’t the tech giant’s first run-in with the Justice Department. In a case widely publicized, the company was accused of colluding with publishers to fix eBook prices. Apple agreed to host an antitrust monitor on campus as part of a settlement, who The Verge report says may or may not be a part of the investigation at hand.

Apple’s music service has been years in the making. After purchasing Beats Electronics, the company has reportedly overhauled the Beats Music as the backbone of its new service. Since then, Apple has slowly secured the exclusive rights to stream “more than a dozen [artists],” including Florence and the Machine and Taylor Swift, and has recently signed on well-respected talent from the BBC’s renowned Radio 1 station to help with logistics and music curation. The service is expected to be woven into the iTunes platform and integrate Beats-style personalization including cloud-based libraries and music recommendations.

Rumors peg June as the unveiling month for Apple’s offering, most likely at the company’s annual Worldwide Developer Conference (WWDC). The most recent iOS update may be a subtle hint — it introduces a redesigned Music app with global search, a new MiniPlayer, and interface improvements across the board. We’ll keep an eye on new developments regarding fair play as the service approaches launch, so stay tuned.

Kyle Wiggers
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kyle Wiggers is a writer, Web designer, and podcaster with an acute interest in all things tech. When not reviewing gadgets…
How much is Apple Music, and how can you get it for free?
Apple Music pricing September 2024.

Apple Music has become one of the top music streaming services globally, second only to Spotify, providing subscribers access to over 100 million songs, curated playlists, and exclusive content. Since its launch in 2015, Apple Music has consistently grown its library and features, seamlessly integrating with the broader Apple ecosystem to deliver a high-quality user experience. It has become a popular choice for music lovers and a strong competitor to other streaming platforms.

Apple Music's pricing structure is a crucial part of its market strategy, aiming to balance affordability with its value proposition to attract a wide range of users, catering to individuals, families, and students.

Read more
Tidal vs. Spotify: Which music streaming service has the features you need?
Tidal home page on iPhone.

If you in the midst of choosing which music streaming service is best for you, when comparing Spotify and Tidal, price is an important, but not the only, factor to consider. Spotify stands out with its flexible subscription options, offering individual, family, and student plans, each with its own unique benefits. In contrast, Tidal offers various subscription plans, too, but Tidal's calling card is that it includes premium and hi-fi options, with the hi-fi plan providing access to lossless, hi-res audio. Spotify does not offer this ... yet.

Spotify uses the Ogg Vorbis and AAC audio formats for streaming, delivering audio at varying bitrates. At the same time, Tidal's hi-fi subscription offers lossless, CD-quality audio and hi-res audio files in FLAC and HiRes FLAC formats.

Read more
Tubi is now available on Apple Vision Pro
A press image of Tubi on Apple Vision Pro.

The biggest free ad-supported streaming service is now available on Apple Vision Pro. Tubi -- the Fox-owned service that has more than 250,000 movies and TV episodes, and more than 250 live channels -- can now be loaded onto Apple's VR platform. It's still free, and it still has ads, of course. And the inclusion on Apple Vision Pro brings the number of platforms Tubi supports to just shy of three dozen.

You can watch Tubi on Apple Vision Pro in the U.S., Australia, and Canada.

Read more