Skip to main content

Consumer Reports cuts Tesla ratings over automatic emergency braking

2016 Tesla Model S P100D
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Consumer Reports lowered its ratings for the Tesla Model S and Model X because autonomous emergency braking was not available in newer cars. The feature had been available in older cars, and Tesla announced it was rolling out a software update to add it back almost immediately after Consumer Reports confirmed the ratings downgrade.

Tesla told media outlets that it was rolling out the update yesterday. Consumer Reports awards two points on its rating scale for cars that have autonomous emergency braking standard, as it feels the technology is an important safety feature. The magazine said it would reevaluate the Tesla ratings once it confirmed that all customer cars had been updated, and that the feature was available on new cars.

Recommended Videos

The issue is related to Tesla’s decision to switch to a new sensor suite for its Autopilot and other driver-assist systems. All cars built since October 2016 have the new “Hardware 2” setup, and weren’t available with autonomous emergency braking when they were delivered to customers. Tesla had indicated the feature would be added back relatively soon, but Consumer Reports said it kept customers waiting too long.

“Hardware 2” includes a greater array of sensors than the previous “Hardware 1” setup, to the extent that Tesla CEO Elon Musk believes it could enable fully autonomous driving. But the software is less comprehensive: besides autonomous emergency braking, the “Hardware 2” cars shipped without some of the Autopilot features that were available on “Hardware 1” cars. Tesla launched a software update in December for a small number of cars to add those features back, and announced a larger-scale rollout last month.

Consumer Reports reduced the Model S’ score from 87 points to 85 points, knocking it out of the top spot in the “ultra luxury category.” The Model S is now in third place, behind the BMW 7 Series and Lexus LS. The Model X’s score was lowered from 58 points to 56 points, putting the SUV close to the bottom in its category.

Consumer Reports initially had a favorable view of Tesla, but things have gone downhill since then. It called the Model S P85D the best car it had ever tested, but was less keen on the Model X. The Model S also hasn’t scored well in the magazine’s reliability rankings, admittedly not unusual for complex luxury cars. Consumer Reports has also taken issue with Tesla’s Autopilot system, viewing it as “too much autonomy, too soon.” Still, Tesla topped its 2016 customer satisfaction rankings.

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Tesla recalls 135,000 vehicles over touchscreen safety issue
Tesla Model 3

Tesla has agreed to recall around 135,000 of its electric vehicles to fix a safety-related issue with the touchscreen.

Affected vehicles include Model S sedans model years 2012 through 2018, and Model X SUVs model years 2016 through 2018.

Read more
A gaming Tesla? New Model S to use same GPU as PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X
Displays in a Tesla Model S.

Tesla's newly redesigned Model S sedan for 2021 could be the perfect road trip companion. Alongside a top cruising speed of 200 miles per hour, you're also getting the power of Sony's PlayStation 5 inside your ride to keep you entertained for the entire journey.

In its press announcement in late January, Tesla didn't reveal which processor or GPU will be powering its 2021 Model S, but we are now learning that the rig could be powered by the same AMD graphics architecture found across game consoles and PCs. A leaked schematic posted by Patrick Schur revealed Tesla could be using AMD's Navi 23 graphics processor inside the new Model S, which would mean that the car would share the same RDNA 2 architecture as some popular gaming systems.

Read more
Tesla gives the Model S over 1,000 hp and a spaceship-like steering wheel
2021 Tesla Model S

Released in 2012, the Model S is the oldest member of the Tesla range. It's about to look a lot newer than its age suggests thanks to a much-needed update that brings a fully redesigned interior and a lot more power.

Not much has changed on the outside, and the sedan remains recognizable as a Model S. Look closely and you might notice stylists gave it a nip-and-tuck that brings a redesigned front bumper, small aerodynamic tweaks out back, and new wheels. Visually, it takes a well-trained eye to tell the latest evolution of the S apart from its predecessor.

Read more