Skip to main content

Judge nixes Uber safe rides fee-related $28.5 million settlement offer

uber settles driver background check case man driving in car the city ride share lyft getaround zipcar
Lightpoet/Shutterstock
Uber hasn’t been faring too well with settlement offers this year. In August in San Francisco, a District Court judge rejected a $100 million settlement with Uber drivers in a suit addressing the question of whether the drivers should be classified as employees or contractors. Now a different judge in the same courthouse rejected Uber’s $28.5 million settlement offer in a lawsuit relating to safe rides fees, according to Bloomberg.

Starting in April 2014 Uber instituted a safe rides fee of $1 per trip. The fee was charged to passengers and was supposed to compensate Uber for driver background checks, vehicle checks, and insurance. In some cities the fee eventually got as high as $2.50 per trip.

Recommended Videos

In the class action lawsuit, riders alleged that driver background checks weren’t as stringent as Uber promised. In a similar suit in April, which was settled for $10 million, prosecutors said drivers who got through the background checks included thieves, burglars, a kidnapper, and a convicted murderer.

Please enable Javascript to view this content

Uber’s $28.5 million offer was rejected because it fell far short of the revenue Uber realized from the fees. Bloomberg reported that, as a result of improper redaction, a copy of the court rejection order revealed that Uber took in $448,598,018 in safe rides fees. That amount is 16 times the amount of the settlement offer. The plaintiffs’ attorneys estimated they would recover $132 million if they won the case, or a full third of the fee revenue Uber took in during the period at issue.

If the offer had been accepted, it would have resulted in approximately 82 cents for each of class action member. U.S. District Judge Jon Tigar ruled that a positive portrayal of that amount in comparison to the average $1.12 charged for safe ride fees “rings hollow” since many in the group paid multiple fees and some passengers paid nothing.

“In sum, the proposed settlement does not fairly and reasonably protect the class,” Tigar wrote.

The next step in the case is for the lawyers to present briefs on why the revenue figures should be sealed. Although the judge gave the attorneys five days to prepare their arguments, the improperly redacted document let the cat out of the bag.

Bruce Brown
Bruce Brown Contributing Editor   As a Contributing Editor to the Auto teams at Digital Trends and TheManual.com, Bruce…
Mini’s infotainment system is very charming, but still needs work
Main screen of the Mini infotainment system

When you think Mini, you probably don’t think of infotainment. Personally, I think of the British flag taillights, the distinct exterior, and the surprising room on the inside. But after driving the Mini John Cooper Works Countryman over the past week, infotainment might well be something I think of more often when it comes to Mini. It’s charming.

It also, however, suffers from all the traps that other legacy automakers fall into when it comes to software design. Mini has something on its hands here — but it still needs some work.
Bringing the charm
The first thing that stood out to me about the system when I got in the car was how fun it was. That all starts with the display. It’s round! No, it’s not curved — the screen is a big, round display sits in at 9.4 inches, and I found it plenty large enough for day-to-day use.

Read more
Plug-in hybrids are becoming more popular. Why? And will it continue?
Kia Niro EV Charging Port

There's a lot of talk about the idea that the growth in electric car sales has kind of slowed a little. It's not all that surprising -- EVs are still expensive, early adopters all have one by now, and they're still new enough to where there aren't too many ultra-affordable used EVs available. But plenty of people still want a greener vehicle, and that has given rise to an explosion in hybrid vehicle sales.

That's especially true of plug-in hybrid vehicles, which can be charged like an EV and driven in all-electric mode for short distances, and have a gas engine as a backup for longer distances or to be used in combination with electric mode for more efficient driving.

Read more
EV drivers are not going back to gas cars, global survey says
ev drivers are not going back to gas cars global survey says screenshot

Nearly all current owners of electric vehicles (EVs) are either satisfied or very satisfied with the experience, and 92% of them plan to buy another EV, according to a survey by the Global EV Drivers Alliance.

The survey of 23,000 EV drivers worldwide found that only 1% would return to a petrol or diesel car, while 4% would opt for a plug-in hybrid (PHEV) if they had to replace their car.

Read more