Skip to main content

Does the Chromecast have what it takes to convert HTPC diehards?

can the chromecast replace your htpc p1090340
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Late last month, Google stunned us all when it released the Chromecast HDMI dongle, a $35 streaming stick that’s capable of bringing Netflix, YouTube, and Google Play content to your HDTV, as well as the ability to mirror a Chrome browser tab on your television. I’ve already deemed it a viable replacement for my WD TV Live streaming box, but does the Chromecast have what it takes to replace the robustness of my home theater PC? 

I have a custom-built HTPC sitting in my living room that is responsible for almost everything I watch on my TV (besides live television, for which I have a simple antenna to get basic channels). I mostly use it to watch Netflix shows, and any other movies and TV shows that I have stored locally on my NAS that sits in the home office. Of course, my HTPC is capable of much more, like playing games and even using it as a DVR. I hardly take advantage of those features, but they’re at least there if I ever want to use them.

Recommended Videos

However, it definitely wasn’t a cheap home theater option for me. I spent a little under $300 for it, using cheap components that wouldn’t necessarily be good for a main computer, but are good enough to use for basic multimedia tasks. It can play 1080p video without glitching or lagging behind, but I’m sure the internal components are in high gear whenever I pop in a Blu-ray movie.

Then the Chromecast came out. I knew right away that it could replace my WD TV Live streaming media box in my bedroom without a second thought, but it got me wondering whether it could replace my HTPC. The short answer is no, but I really wish it could. There are a few big, obvious sacrifices to be made if I switched to the Chromecast, namely the streaming limitations of the dongle, with support for only Netflix, YouTube, and Google Play content.

Chromecast

Chromecast woes

However, the Chromecast suffers from far more than just limited content when comparing it to HTPCs. For instance, the Chromecast can play locally-stored content, but it’s a bit tricky and hardly worth it. Google clearly sees it as a workaround for now, but it requires that local files be played through the Chrome Web browser by copying and pasting the file path into the address bar. From there, you can beam it to the Chromecast using the Google Cast Chrome extension. Yes, it works, but it’s certainly not as quick and easy as just double-clicking a video file and having it play in the media player of your choice. Plus, HTPCs can play any file type you throw at them with the right media players and codecs installed, although I was bit surprised that I was able to beam an .MKV file through the Chrome browser.

In general, the Netflix and YouTube streaming capabilities on the Chromecast are good, but one of my biggest gripes is that Netflix doesn’t automatically play the next episode in a TV series when using the Chromecast. That’s one thing I love about the Web interface: I can binge-watch a TV show without having to reach over and click to play the next episode every time. After a show stops playing on the Chromecast, the Netflix app goes back to the main screen. From there, the app will show what you recently watched at the top. Most users would think that tapping on the TV show you just watched would play the next episode, but it actually just repeats the same episode.

Instead, you have to navigate your way to the list of episodes for that show and select the next episode, making it extremely inconvenient to do any kind of binge watching (perhaps my eyes should thank Google?). I hope Netflix gets enough complaints that it’ll be obligated to fix this, but I’m not really holding my breath.

Google Chromecast

Help is on the way

Of course, the limitations of the Chromecast have already been a huge turn-off for prospective buyers, dashing any hopes of it being the ultimate streaming device for some. However, that’s quickly changing. Numerous other services have already chimed in with upcoming support for the Chromecast, including Hulu, HBO, Pandora, Vimeo, Redbox Instant, and more. Thanks to the Chromecast SDK that Google released, we should be seeing a healthy dose of streaming services make their way to the Chromecast soon.

Plus, Google has room to improve the Chromecast as a device itself. Many of the features are still in beta, including the Chrome browser mirroring, and it’s almost guaranteed that this will get better and better as time goes on. There’s also room to add more features to the device, including the possibility of mirroring your actual desktop, rather than having to rely on the Chrome browser. There’s also a Plex Chromecast app in the works that will be able to stream and handle local files on your network that are located either on your computer or a NAS – this could be huge.

We also can’t forget about the possibility of hacks to further extend the capabilities of the Chromecast, although that almost seems like a distant thought now, since Google recently (and rather quickly) patched up a hole that allowed hackers to root the device. This has us wondering whether Google is looking to keep the Chromecast platform a bit more closed off than Android, but it may just be a sign that Google isn’t quite ready for hackers to take a hold of the Chromecast just yet.

Chromecast vs. Apple TV

One of the biggest pluses of replacing my HTPC with a Chromecast is that it would allow me to make more room on the TV stand. The Chromecast is literally out-of-sight, and if I need to take it with me when I travel, I just yank it out of its HDMI port and throw it in my bag without any hassle, that way I can have Netflix in my hotel room or at a friend’s house whenever I want; it would be like having an HTPC with me wherever I go. Of course, there’s the required microUSB cable, but I always keep one of those in my bag anyway.

To Chromecast or not to Chromecast?

When it all comes down to it, I’m a very frugal and minimalistic person, so the Chromecast fits right into my wheelhouse. I would throw out my shoebox-sized HTPC in a heartbeat in favor of the Chromecast if it could offer close to the same functionality – but it doesn’t. It’s simply not meant to be an HTPC replacement and it never will be.

After attempting to exclusively use the Chromecast on my living room TV, it just left me missing my HTPC more and more. There are simply too many capabilities to count that an HTPC can do that the Chromecast can’t: play games, watch live TV, record live TV, play DVD/Blu-ray movies, store files, and not to mention access to a full desktop OS with a file system that you can easily navigate (the Chromecast relies on other devices for all of that, which can be cumbersome).

Even if the Chromecast had all these capabilities, the lack of an Ethernet port is huge; doing any kind of streaming wirelessly is a cause for trouble, unless you have an incredibly good Wi-Fi signal, which is next to impossible 99 percent of the time.

The Chromecast is an extremely promising piece of technology, but it just doesn’t have the bevy of features that it needs, which is really the only problem it faces right now. Of course, there’s also the streaming boxes like the Apple TV and Roku, which are also pretty inexpensive and robust; but $35 is unbeatable, and the Chromecast will keep getting better – hopefully to the point that it’s capable of performing just as well as, or even better than, an Apple TV or Roku. However, there’s just no way that it’ll ever perform as well as an HTPC.

Craig Lloyd
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Craig Lloyd is a freelance writer who's been writing and blogging since 2008. His love for technology goes back even further…
Spotify vs. Pandora: which streaming service should you choose?
spotify vs pandora on iphone

Let's settle a musical debate: which music streaming platform should you use: Spotify or Pandora?

Both services have their unique strengths and weaknesses. Spotify boasts a more extensive music catalog, robust social features for sharing and discovering music with friends, and a more polished user experience across devices.

Read more
Ryzen AI nearly hits 60 fps in Black Myth: Wukong, but it’s not that simple
OneXFly F1 Pro gamig handheld.

Although AMD APUs appear in some of the best gaming handhelds, the latest Strix Point chips are still hard to find in new releases. However, the new OneXFly F1 Pro gamin handheld is making its debut with the Ryzen AI HX 370 chip in tow, and according to a benchmark in Black Myth: Wukong, it managed to average an impressive 58 frames per second (fps) at a 15-watt thermal design power (TDP). That's an impressive result, but digging deeper reveals that AAA gaming on the go is still not without any sacrifice.

The OneXFly F1 Pro comes with the Ryzen AI HX 370, which sports a total of 12 cores -- four Zen 5 and eight Zen 5c -- as well as 24 threads. The maximum boost clock on the Zen 5 cores reaches 5.1GHz, but the smaller Zen 5c maxes out at 3.3GHz. The default TDP was rated at 28 watts, but it can be configured between 15W and 54W. For an APU, the AI HX 370 delivers solid graphics capabilities, as it's equipped with the AMD Radeon 890M. It also sports a 7-inch OLED screen with a refresh rate of 144Hz.

Read more
Best Buy laptop deals: Cheap laptops starting at $200
Apple M1 MacBook Air open on a desk with plants in the background.

Best Buy is one of the best retailers to shop if you're looking for some of today’s best laptop deals. Whether you need something high end or more entry-level, Best Buy likely has a laptop that’s perfectly priced for you The Best Buy laptop deals going on right now include Dell laptop deals, HP laptop deals, Lenovo laptop deals, and even MacBook deals. With so much to choose from we thought we’d narrow down all of the Best Buy deals worth taking a look at. Reading onward you’ll find all the details you need in order to save on a new laptop at Best Buy, and if you aren’t finding what you’re looking for you can find some laptop deals among the current Amazon deals and Walmart deals as well.
HP 14-inch laptop — $200 $250 20% off

The HP 14-inch laptop is a sleek and fun computing device. It's a great option for anyone searching the best laptops for high school students or the best laptops for college. It has an Intel Pentium processor and 4GB of system RAM that combine to push through homework assignments, work presentations, and hours upon hours of binge watching. The 14-inch screen sports HD resolution and makes this HP laptop a great way to enjoy movies, photos, and other digital content. The HP 14-inch laptop is able to reach up to 14 hours of battery life on a single charge, making it a great all-day option for people who like to do their work on the go.

Read more