Skip to main content

Hands on: Intel RealSense 3D

RealSense is a half-baked research product that’s been unleashed on the public well before it’s done.

Intel devoted most of its CES 2014 press conference to its new RealSense 3D camera, a device that’s very much like Kinect for a laptop computer. This camera will be bundled into numerous Ultrabooks and tablets by mid-year, and will enable software never before possible. Interactive 3D books, real-time virtual sculpting and on-the-fly video editing are just some of the possibilities hinted at.

Recommended Videos

To see the technology for ourselves, we made our way over to Intel’s booth, where a variety of demos were on display. We didn’t have to play with them long to realize that RealSense isn’t ready for launch. Indeed, using it brings back scarring memories of the Leap sensor, which disappointed us last year.

We started off with a gesture-based music app that was shown at Intel’s conference. This was the most convincing demo on-stage, so we expected it to work well in person. It didn’t. The camera seemed to have a hard time picking up any gestures at all unless we stood within a narrow range and, even then, only some of the app’s gestures worked. Others, like giving a camera a thumbs-up to increase the tempo of the background music, were never recognized.

Another demo, a game called 3D pinball, tasked us with using our hands to deflect a ball bouncing between the foreground and targets in the background. While the game had no problem locating a hand held before the camera, movement was not smooth and instead came in jerks and starts. This, of course, made the game rather frustrating, as we couldn’t aim the ball where we wanted or reliably hit it.

The only demo that worked somewhat well was Hoplites, a game built in the style of Angry Birds with the goal of helping a squad of cute cartoon warriors safely reach their destination. Doing this requires the use of various hand gestures to bridge chasms, block fireballs and ward off monsters. Though the game often perceived us as thumbless, it at least detected hand movement quickly and smoothly.

On the whole, then, the verdict is simple: RealSense doesn’t work very well. In fact, we think it’s fair to say it works poorly. Kinect 2 is light-years ahead, and even the Leap is a step forward.

Using the camera – and watching others use the camera – did no favors for Intel’s argument that gesture input is more “natural” than touch. While the company’s ever-smiling floor staff was eager to show people what to do, there was still no shortage of flailing hands and confused faces. The technology sparks curiosity, but it fails to follow up, and loses its interest once the initial charm of interaction gives way to reality; RealSense isn’t any good.

What most baffles us most is the fact that Intel is acting as if this technology, which clearly isn’t ready, will change the world. Maybe it could, one day. But if it does, it won’t be because of RealSense. All this immature product does is sour people to 3D sensors, making the path to acceptance harder for future products that may (hopefully) work better.

Highs

  • Should be “free” when bundled in PCs

Lows

  • Fast movement can fool the camera
  • Works only within a limited range
  • Software support is very immature
Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Samsung reveals details on its glasses-free, 3D gaming monitor
The Samsung Odyssey 3D monitor placed on a desk.

Samsung’s new Odyssey 3D monitor was a hit at CES earlier this year, showcasing a comfortable and immersive 3D gaming experience -- all without the need for special glasses. But details were scarce.

Now, it's being shown off again along with the new game announcements Gamescom to drum up more interest -- and revealing some of the juicy details behind the tech.

Read more
AMD on the Ryzen 7 9800X3D: ‘We have a lot to say’
A delidded Ryzen 7000 CPU.

AMD just revealed its Ryzen 9000 chips at Computex 2024, but the company is already working on its versions of these processors with 3D V-Cache. These X3D variants, as they're called, have been a mainstay of AMD's lineup since the Ryzen 7 5800X3D, and they consistently rank among the best gaming processors. AMD's Donny Woligroski says the company is "not just resting on laurels," and that it has some big plans for the next version of X3D chips.

The news comes from PC Gamer, which shared various quotes from an interview with Woligroski. Although we've known for a while that 3D V-Cache would come to Ryzen 9000 eventually, Woligroski says that AMD is pushing the tech forward. "It's not like, 'hey, we've also added X3D to a chip.' We are working actively on really cool differentiators to make it even better. We're working on X3D, we're improving it," Woligroski told PC Gamer.

Read more
Acer’s new 3D camera can stream directly to YouTube or to a Zoom call
The SpatialLabs Eyes 3D camera being used in front of a woman.

Acer has announced its first 3D camera, the SpatialLabs Eyes Stereo, just ahead of Computex 2024 next week. The camera can do both 3D photos and video, which can then be viewed within the camera itself, in a VR headset, or on a 3D display.

You might be wondering what a PC company is doing selling a 3D camera, but Acer has been on the forefront of 3D tech for years now -- primarily focused on stereoscopic displays in external monitors and laptops. But now, the company has a proper camera for content capture.

Read more