The Justice Department won’t help the FCC fight against local broadband restrictions

By Jonathan Keane November 9, 2015

net neutrality in jeopardy trump administration fcc tom wheeler 2 — Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) was dealt a blow last week, with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) saying it would not assist the agency in any legal action against individual states’ broadband laws.

In its filing dated November 5, the DOJ stated briefly that “it takes no position in these cases.” The filing was referring to two specific cases that the FCC is facing against Tennessee and North Carolina. The state laws would restrict local city-run broadband projects. Refusing to take a position means the DOJ will leave the FCC to argue its point on its own.

Recommended Videos

The DOJ’s decision comes despite Obama’s administration previously backing such projects.

Locally run ISPs had asked the FCC for help in pre-empting what they called unfair state laws that hindered their ability to compete with larger ISPs. Municipal broadband providers are itching to expand their reach and offer more services, but often they are restricted by state laws.

Randolph May, a former FCC lawyer and currently a member of the Free State Foundation think tank, writes that the DOJ decision is very rare and questions the legality of the FCC’s pre-emptive moves against state laws.

“We don’t know for sure, but my best guess is that the DOJ, quite rightly, is concerned about the lawfulness of the FCC’s preemption action. If so, the concern is justified,” he said.

The DOJ still supports the FCC’s move to reclassify broadband companies as common carriers under net neutrality rules.

The Washington Post reports that if the FCC’s cases that oppose city restrictions on local broadband projects are indeed weak, it could have long term effects on the future of locally-built broadband. The Telecommunications Act, for example, does not specifically state if the FCC can pre-empt state laws. The FCC has not yet commented on the DOJ’s decision.

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…

Computing

The compact Dell XPS 13 is on sale for one of the lowest prices we’ve seen

Dell XPS 13 9345 front view showing display and keyboard.

The Dell XPS 13 used to go on sale all the time, and was often included in some of the best laptop deals. That hasn’t happened for a bit. However, today we spotted the Dell XPS 13 with Snapdragon X Elite processor at a huge discount. Usually, it's $1,300, but right now you can buy it for $1,000 saving you $200. Ideal for anyone who desires excellent style and form, this Dell XPS 13 makes for a solid last-minute purchase before the holidays. It's also extra compact and portable while still being suitably powerful for work and school. Here’s all you need to know about it before you tap the buy button below.

Why you should buy the Dell XPS 13
Our Dell XPS 13 review explains all you need to know about the system in-depth. Simply put, it provides excellent build quality, it’s thin and light, has great battery life, and provides exceptional performance too. We really love the compact and lightweight design that serves the portable nature well. You can take it and use it virtually anywhere. That makes it so great for school, work, or some productive tasks.

Computing

Best laptop deals: Save on the Dell XPS 14, MacBook Pro 16 and more

The Dell XPS 14 on a white table with the screen open.

There are a lot of great laptop options out there, especially with some of the best laptop brands out there starting to branch out beyond what they are usually known for. That means that you can snag anything from an excellent 2-in-1 to a gaming laptop while still finding excellent deals. Of course, you don't need the best laptops to get something that's pretty great quality and can even compete with desktop computers, so if you want something budget-oriented, you're in luck.
That's why we've gone out and collected these deals from the best brands; you'll find HP laptop deals, Dell laptop deals, Acer laptop deals, Lenovo laptop deals, and more. They run the gamut from Chromebook deals and 2-in-1 laptop deals to powerful gaming laptop deals and everything in between.

HP Chromebook 14a -- $220 $320 31% off

Computing

This 17-inch HP Envy laptop is $380 off today

The opened HP Envy 17t-da000 with an abstract background.

Sometimes, all you need is a classic laptop with a tried and true reputation. Combining power and performance, HP is a brand that delivers consistently good laptops, which is why we’re glad to shine a light on this offer: For a limited time when you order the HP Envy 17t Laptop through the manufacturer, you’ll save $380. At full price, this model sells for $1,150.

Why you should buy the HP Envy 17t Laptop
There’s nothing like a solid Windows PC to get you through a work or school day (we also have a list of great student laptop deals!). The HP Envy 17t is also a great laptop to chill out with at the end of a long shift. Under the hood, this Envy 17t configuration runs an Intel Core Ultra 5 with Intel Arc Graphics, 16GB of RAM, and 512GB of storage. You’ll also get a 17.3-inch IPS screen that brings 1920 x 1080 resolution and 300-nit peak brightness levels to the table.