Skip to main content

Not before time, pro soccer will finally start testing in-game video replays

SeatGeek
Sportgraphic/123RF
Considering how many years it took soccer to get around to the idea of goal-line technology, let alone to actually start using it, the sport can seem rather behind the times to many.

So get this: FIFA, the sport’s governing body, said Thursday it’s looking to expand its use of technology in the game by introducing … wait for it … video replays for officials, something that’s been used in major U.S. sports for years now.

Recommended Videos

Testing of its new Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system, which’ll serve to help officials call difficult decisions, is expected to start early next year, with Major League Soccer (MLS) one of those chosen to trial the technology. Germany’s Bundesliga, Australia’s Hyundai A-League, and several soccer tournaments in Brazil will also be involved.

“Major League Soccer has been a strong proponent of using technology in soccer where it enhances the game, and we are pleased to be among the first leagues in the world to participate in the VAR project,” Don Garber, MLS Commissioner, said in a release. He added it was now time “for a mechanism that helps referees avoid clearly incorrect decisions that change the game.”

Just like in American sports, the system offers a booth-based official the ability to view video that shows events on the field from multiple angles. When called upon, they can quickly review a play and communicate with on-field officials to help with important decisions such as goals, penalty and offside decisions, and red card incidents.

It seems much of soccer’s resistance to technology came from former FIFA president Sepp Blatter, who left the post last year amid a corruption scandal involving a number of the governing body’s officials.

Blatter, who held soccer’s top job for 17 years, had always maintained that the sport should keep its “human face” and reject new technology, claiming that debate among fans around controversial decisions made the game more exciting.

Lampard's goal that wasn't a goal.
Lampard’s goal that wasn’t a goal. Image used with permission by copyright holder

But in 2010 he had a change of heart after witnessing an incident at the World Cup Finals in South Africa when the England team scored a clear goal in a game against Germany – only for the ref to rule that the ball didn’t go over the line. Had he seen what millions of soccer fans around the world saw on their TVs at home – including endless slow-motion replays of the ball passing over the line – he would obviously have given the goal.

With so much money in the game today, and players’ and managers’ careers possibly dependent on crucial decisions made during a game, the only surprise is that it’s taken this long for FIFA to finally start looking at ways to bring video replays into the sport.

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
Range Rover’s first electric SUV has 48,000 pre-orders
Land Rover Range Rover Velar SVAutobiography Dynamic Edition

Range Rover, the brand made famous for its British-styled, luxury, all-terrain SUVs, is keen to show it means business about going electric.

And, according to the most recent investor presentation by parent company JLR, that’s all because Range Rover fans are showing the way. Not only was demand for Range Rover’s hybrid vehicles up 29% in the last six months, but customers are buying hybrids “as a stepping stone towards battery electric vehicles,” the company says.

Read more
BYD’s cheap EVs might remain out of Canada too
BYD Han

With Chinese-made electric vehicles facing stiff tariffs in both Europe and America, a stirring question for EV drivers has started to arise: Can the race to make EVs more affordable continue if the world leader is kept out of the race?

China’s BYD, recognized as a global leader in terms of affordability, had to backtrack on plans to reach the U.S. market after the Biden administration in May imposed 100% tariffs on EVs made in China.

Read more
Tesla posts exaggerate self-driving capacity, safety regulators say
Beta of Tesla's FSD in a car.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is concerned that Tesla’s use of social media and its website makes false promises about the automaker’s full-self driving (FSD) software.
The warning dates back from May, but was made public in an email to Tesla released on November 8.
The NHTSA opened an investigation in October into 2.4 million Tesla vehicles equipped with the FSD software, following three reported collisions and a fatal crash. The investigation centers on FSD’s ability to perform in “relatively common” reduced visibility conditions, such as sun glare, fog, and airborne dust.
In these instances, it appears that “the driver may not be aware that he or she is responsible” to make appropriate operational selections, or “fully understand” the nuances of the system, NHTSA said.
Meanwhile, “Tesla’s X (Twitter) account has reposted or endorsed postings that exhibit disengaged driver behavior,” Gregory Magno, the NHTSA’s vehicle defects chief investigator, wrote to Tesla in an email.
The postings, which included reposted YouTube videos, may encourage viewers to see FSD-supervised as a “Robotaxi” instead of a partially automated, driver-assist system that requires “persistent attention and intermittent intervention by the driver,” Magno said.
In one of a number of Tesla posts on X, the social media platform owned by Tesla CEO Elon Musk, a driver was seen using FSD to reach a hospital while undergoing a heart attack. In another post, a driver said he had used FSD for a 50-minute ride home. Meanwhile, third-party comments on the posts promoted the advantages of using FSD while under the influence of alcohol or when tired, NHTSA said.
Tesla’s official website also promotes conflicting messaging on the capabilities of the FSD software, the regulator said.
NHTSA has requested that Tesla revisit its communications to ensure its messaging remains consistent with FSD’s approved instructions, namely that the software provides only a driver assist/support system requiring drivers to remain vigilant and maintain constant readiness to intervene in driving.
Tesla last month unveiled the Cybercab, an autonomous-driving EV with no steering wheel or pedals. The vehicle has been promoted as a robotaxi, a self-driving vehicle operated as part of a ride-paying service, such as the one already offered by Alphabet-owned Waymo.
But Tesla’s self-driving technology has remained under the scrutiny of regulators. FSD relies on multiple onboard cameras to feed machine-learning models that, in turn, help the car make decisions based on what it sees.
Meanwhile, Waymo’s technology relies on premapped roads, sensors, cameras, radar, and lidar (a laser-light radar), which might be very costly, but has met the approval of safety regulators.

Read more