Skip to main content

Just another Star Wars game? Jedi: Fallen Order struggles to stand out

Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order
Image used with permission by copyright holder

At E3 2019, EA and Respawn Entertainment gave us our first look at Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order. During the preview, we were shown Padawan Cal Kestis and his Droid BD-1 as they embark on a mini-adventure on the planet Kashyyyk.

From hijacking a Walker and platforming through treacherous overgrown landscapes, to getting ambushed by a giant spider and using the force to fight off a group of Empire baddies, Fallen Order looks stunningly cinematic and right on brand for a single-player Star Wars experience.

Recommended Videos

It’s so on brand, in fact, that it left little room for surprise.

The focus of the gameplay is combat, traversal, and the role BD-1 plays as a companion. It starts off with Cal scaling to the top of Walker, fighting off Stormtrooper pilots, and assuming control. A holographic message of an enemy demanding the status of the Walker goes off in the pit, and Cal asks BD-1 to take care of it. The droid happily assists and shuts the holographic message off.

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Official Gameplay Demo – EA PLAY 2019

This is our first real peek into the relationship between Cal and his droid, and it continues to play out through the preview. In another moment, Cal scales a wall and with the help of BD-1’s Overcharge ability, is able to move it out the way and continue moving forward. We also see BD-1 provide Cal a bit of healing. Cal speaks to BD-1 like a pet for maximum cute.

The adorable BD-1 and Cal’s relationship resembles that of Luke and R2D2 and Rey and BB-8 in the movies. It’s a mechanic that seems to add charm to gameplay, though the moment revealed so far are more for cinematic flourish and don’t impact how the game plays.

That might change, as we caught a glimpse of a BD-1 skill tree in the menu. That alludes to more advanced assistance in the later parts of the game. Perhaps BD-1 will become a tool in your toolbox as well as an amusing companion.

It’s a Star Wars game

Combat is fluid and flashy. Cal wields a lightsaber, of course, and uses the power of the force to fight off enemies. In traditional Jedi style, he pulls in enemies and strikes them down stylishly in between acrobatic moves. He also uses his lightsaber to deflect bullets and parry attacks, as well as execute a finisher where he drives his lightsaber into the chest of a Stormtrooper.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

It looks entertaining, and very reminiscent of Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. With Respawn Entertainment spearheading development, it gives the impression that Fallen Order will feel tight and precise.

The most striking element, and most subtle, was the minimalist HUD. It’s unclear if that will carry over to later versions of the game, but keeping the HUD to the bare essentials helped maintain the cinematic look. On the bottom left corner is a health and stamina bar, and the occasional skillpoint notification would pop up on the top right hand corner. The transition from cutscene to gameplay was unnoticeable, and the developers revealed that this was intentionally done to make Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order feel more cinematic.

There’s that word again. Cinematic. Everything about Fallen Order seems bound to it, for better or worse.

Story, though, is still largely unknown. We know it takes place after the events of Revenge of the Sith, and we know propaganda against the Jedi is at a critical point. Cal is a young Jedi up against the Empire accompanied by a cute new droid, and a group of rebel characters in supporting roles.

And that’s a bit disappointing. I’ve heard this story many times before.

A cameo made by Rogue One’s Saw Gerrera, played by Forest Whitaker, brought a little extra life to the gameplay reveal. It’s unclear, however, if he will play a significant role in the game. None of the larger plot points or character have been revealed — aside from Cal and BD-1, of course.

If Fallen Order keeps its minimalist HUD and hidden loading screens, it’s sure to be one of the most cinematic and immersive Star Wars games to date. It also risks feeling too familiar. Respawn has said Fallen Order will be a narrative driven experience. I just hope it isn’t a cliche.

Felicia Miranda
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Born in '89 and raised through the 90s, I experienced what I consider to be the golden age of video games. At an early age, I…
Star Wars Outlaws’ open world looks less overwhelming than other Ubisoft games
A ship flies through space in Star Wars Outlaws.

Ubisoft has been taking strides to tweak how it creates open-world games, and that appears to be continuing with Star Wars Outlaws. In an IGN interview published Tuesday, Massive Entertainment developers detailed how a lot of the upcoming game's features were made, and that includes how it handles open-world exploration

Julian Gerighty, Massive creative director, gave more details on how it'll feel to traverse the different planets and moons featured in the game. While many of Ubisoft's worlds have felt too large, Massive seems to have taken a subtle, new approach that could make a big difference. It took into account not only how players will travel on foot but also by speeder.

Read more
With EA’s Star Wars shooter canceled, it’s time to revisit a classic
Star Wars Dark Forces Remaster key art.

Amid a layoff wave at the end of February, EA canceled a Star Wars first-person shooter that was in development at Apex Legends developer Respawn Entertainment. Considering this is a genre that Star Wars once dominated, as well as Respawn’s mastery with games like Titanfall 2, the news especially stung, even if it's small potatoes next to all the jobs lost in EA's layoffs. If you’re yearning for a Star Wars FPS and don’t want to wait for the Star Wars: Battlefront remaster launching later this month, you’re in luck.

On February 28, the Atari-owned Nightdive Studios released Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster. Employing the proprietary KEX Engine used on remasters of classic Turok and Quake games, Nightdive enhanced the 1995 MS-DOS and Macintosh shooter that follows the escapades of Rebel mercenary Kyle Katarn. Playing this game for the first time in 2024, I’ve found that it still holds up immaculately and is worth checking out if you’re worried about the future of Star Wars games.

Read more
Star Wars Jedi: Survivor is the culmination of the series’ rocky gaming history
Jedi Cal Kestis.

I've played Star Wars Jedi: Survivor's Coruscant heist opening multiple times at this point, and every time I play it, I can't help but think about what could've been with Star Wars 1313, the franchise's most infamous canceled game. 
The idea of an Uncharted-like game about Boba Fett fighting throughout the Coruscant underworld is such an excellent pitch that I've grieved the loss of a game I never even had a chance to play for over a decade. Playing through Survivor's opening doesn't elicit feelings of disappointment about 1313, though. Instead, I feel happy that at least some fraction of that idea was able to be realized.

Survivor's Metroidanvia-like level design and Lightsaber-and-Force-based combat are much different than what was promised from 1313. However, the idea of cleverly climbing and fighting across a seedy-looking level of Coruscant during a heist was still realized. Reflecting on the lost project ahead of this year's Star Wars Day, I had a revelation about Respawn Entertainment's latest game. Despite technically being a sequel to just Fallen Order, Star Wars Jedi: Survivor feels like the culmination of over a decade of Star Wars games, both released and canceled, that came before.
A walk through Star Wars gaming history
Growing up, two of my favorite video games were the original Star Wars: Battlefront II and Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. To this day, 2005's Battlefront II is my favorite game of all time, not only because of all the great memories that I had with it but also because it feels like an authentic Star Wars simulator where multiple eras, planets, and characters are preserved in incredible detail. Survivor feels like it has the same keen attention to detail.
Players may not visit as many planets as they do in Battlefront II, but each location in Survivor is densely packed with content and immaculately packed with detailed environments and characters that faithfully represent the High Republic, prequel, and Imperial eras. While the aesthetics feel as detailed as Battlefront, the gameplay fantasy pulls more from The Force Unleashed.

Read more