Skip to main content

Elden Ring players are discovering its comedic brilliance

With Elden Ring finally out, you may have expected that your Twitter feed would fill up with frustrated players cursing out bosses. And while there’s plenty of that out there (I’m looking at you, Margit), it’s not the dominant conversation around the game at the moment. Instead, players are using social media platforms to spotlight just how dang funny the game is.

“Comedy” might not be something you immediately associate with FromSoftware’s games. At a glance, they’re darker than the blackest coffee and their punishing difficulty feels designed to steal smiles. But games like Dark Souls have always had a secret comedic edge, both intentional and not, and that’s even more pronounced in Elden Ring.

Recommended Videos

Make ‘em laugh

FromSoftware knows how to tell a joke through design. When you walk into a room and the floor shoots up into a spiked ceiling, that’s a gag. It’s like they set out a lethal whoopie cushion for players to sit on. Every trap is a pratfall that’s supposed to make you laugh, even if you want to strangle someone.

https://twitter.com/86oz_/status/1497783505803268096

Then there’s the player-created jokes. Like previous FromSoftware games, players can leave messages for others to find. These can be helpful, warning adventurers that they’re about to step into a trap. More often than not, though, they’re a competition for who can create the silliest message with a limited vocabulary. Players are already using the tool to create filthy jokes that would make George Carlin proud.

But there’s unintended humor, too. FromSoftware doesn’t make clean games. They’ve got their own brand of “jank,” which can lead to absurd interactions. They can be caused by enemies going someplace they’re not supposed to be or the camera accidentally hiding a key piece of information like a banana peel. While those can be frustrating during a big boss fight, social media sites are lighting up with some truly hilarious reactions.

THE MOST INSANE THING TO HAPPEN TO ME IN A VIDEO GAMWE IM SCREAMING…. #EldenRing pic.twitter.com/AhL1CzZp1Y

— andy (@andysolxiv) February 28, 2022

minor Elden Ring Spoilers

this game is the funniest fucking game ever pic.twitter.com/uqw2mUOXr5

— JoeLongBalls (@JoeLongBalls) February 27, 2022

https://twitter.com/BengineeringTV/status/1498155317472813057

To reiterate, Elden Ring is hysterical.

The slapstick videos highlight what makes the game so entertaining, even when it’s at its hardest. The Land Between is the world’s deadliest playground. There’s a masochistic glee you feel when something so completely absurd happens to you that you need to post it, because no one would believe you otherwise. In Elden Ring, everyone gets to be an anecdotal comedian.

It’s another of the many ways the game reminds me of the fervor around The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (I’m going to keep making the comparison until it stops holding true). When that game launched, players took to social media to share all the wild sandbox interactions they experienced in the game. We saw everything from hysterical pratfalls down the side of a mountain to knee-slapping enemy kills made possible through Link’s abilities. To this day, I still routinely see videos of people making jokes in that game in ways I never thought were possible.

The comedic timing in Elden Ring really is pitch perfect. pic.twitter.com/PTZiQdqZTq

— Nerium (Nere) (@neriumstrom) March 1, 2022

Elden Ring seems like it’s on the same track. With how gigantic the game is, there are so many opportunities for players to utterly perish in gut-busting ways. I don’t imagine it’ll reach the same heights as Zelda considering that it gives players fewer actions, but I’m already seeing interactions I never knew were possible — and the game has been out for mere days.

If you’re not feeling FOMO by not jumping on Elden Ring, don’t worry: You’re in on the fun without even playing it. These games aren’t for everyone and they can be completely humorless for players just looking to progress. There’s no shame in being an audience member instead of getting on stage. Let the fans entertain you with their deadly escapades and laugh at their expense.

Elden Ring is out now on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S.

Giovanni Colantonio
As Digital Trends' Senior Gaming Editor, Giovanni Colantonio oversees all things video games at Digital Trends. As a veteran…
Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree is already wiping the floor with me
Elden Ring gameplay

Elden Ring was unanimously 2022’s Game of the Year. While many other fantastic games were released throughout the year, Elden Ring shut down all competition when it dropped in early March. It swept at awards shows and even landed a Game of the Year spot here on Digital Trends. It was the undisputed champ. Two years later, it’s now getting the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion. If a DLC ever had a chance at winning the top prize at The Game Awards, it could be this one.

Ahead of its June 21 release, I spent three hours with a hands-on preview of Shadow of the Erdtree. While it doesn’t offer anything drastically different from the base game, it’s still more of the same Elden Ring you love. It has an excellent atmosphere, fun exploration, and difficult bosses. More of the same isn’t a bad thing when that “same” is as beloved as this.
Return to the Lands Between
For those looking to pop in right on June 21, Bandai Namco clarified that players will need to have already beaten the bosses Starscourage Radahn and Mohg, Lord of Blood in order to access the expansion. Additionally, there are over 100 new weapons, some of which are not found in the base game.

Read more
Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree story trailer follows Miquella into the Land of Shadow
A furnace golem looms in Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree.

ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree | Story Trailer

FromSoftware has finally (sort of) revealed the story players will be experiencing in the Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC. As we learned in the reveal trailer, and from comments made by director Hidetaka Miyazaki, it will follow the story of Miquella of the Haligtree (referred to as Miquella the Kind in the trailer).

Read more
I want more approachable Soulslikes. These new games show that it’s possible
Stellar Blade STALKER fight.

One of my favorite copypastas on the internet comes from someone complaining about a player using mods to make a FromSoftware game easier. "You cheated not only the game, but yourself," it reads. "You didn't grow. You didn't improve. You took a shortcut and gained nothing. You experienced a hollow victory. Nothing was risked and nothing was gained. It's sad that you don't know the difference."

The infamous post was made in response to a PC Gamer article about mods that made Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice more approachable for the writer. It's funny to see someone get that angry over another's personal experience with a game they own, but it also addresses a question that's loomed over the gaming community ever since Dark Souls took the world by storm: Should FromSoftware's games and the Soulslikes inspired by them have options to make them more accessible?

Read more