Skip to main content

Lessons learned: Comparing the Xbox Series X and Xbox One launches

Even with a pandemic raging, the launch of the Xbox Series X is less chaotic than the launch of the Xbox One.

Recommended Videos

Microsoft’s current-generation console saw so many policy reversals prior to launch that it earned the less-than-flattering nickname “Xbox 180” — and the first few post-launch days weren’t exactly a walk in the park.

It was a learning experience for the company, but Microsoft seems to have taken those lessons to heart. The Series X has encountered a hurdle or two in the road to its launch, but Microsoft corrected course quickly.

Lesson 1: Listen to customers, not partners, first

Microsoft’s biggest mistake came right out of the gate. At E3, it announced the Xbox One would require consoles to connect to the internet every 24 hours, or games would cease to function — even in single-player modes — along with other restrictive policies on trading and loaning games to friends. Those policies were reversed before launch, but not before the company defended them at E3.

BUILD 2013 Xbox One
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It was a PR debacle. Amazon, in June of that year, polled customers to see which next-gen console they planned to pre-order. The results were staggering, with the PS4 outperforming the Xbox One 18 to 1 — garnering 94% of the vote before the poll was taken down. Microsoft’s planned restrictions confused and angered hardcore and casual gamers alike.

Since unveiling the Xbox Series X last year at E3, Microsoft has avoided those headaches by focusing on what players have asked for, rather than the demands of its publisher partners.

Lesson 2: Don’t start a privacy debate

Kinect, at this point, is a fading memory in most gamer’s minds. But when the Xbox One launched, it was an essential part of the system. It was a pain to set up (you had to run a series of tests to ensure it worked optimally). It didn’t add much to most games,  and major franchises ignored it. It even raised privacy fears among players who didn’t like the idea of a camera watching them when they weren’t playing.

microsoft xbox one review console kinect
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Those concerns were so intense that Congress got involved. The U.S. House of Representatives introduced legislation called the “We Are Watching You Act” (honest, that was the name), which would require companies using a camera-equipped set-top box to display the message “We are watching you” whenever viewers were monitored for any reason. The bill died in committee.

These days, of course, Kinect is dead as a gaming device. And, ironically, people are less freaked out by always-listening devices like Alexa.

Lesson 3: Don’t be cheap

Originally, Microsoft planned to ship the Xbox One without an HDMI cable. A couple of months before launch, it reversed course on that, adding it into the “Day One” edition of the system, along with a chat headset. Fans grumbled the company was nickel-and-diming them with the launch.

The Series X comes with an HDMI cable included, though not with a headset.

Lesson 4: Resolve problems quickly

Post-launch issues happen. Two generations ago, it was the Red Ring of Death on the Xbox 360, something that could’ve been devastating — but the company handled it so well that the Xbox 360 trounced the PlayStation 3 anyway.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

With the Xbox One, a small number of the initial units had an issue with the Blu-ray drive, which rendered it unable to read discs. Microsoft quickly diffused the situation by providing affected users with a free digital download of one of the first-party launch titles (Ryse, Dead Rising 3, or Forza V).

Hopefully, the Series X won’t have any such issues. But if it does, Microsoft has a solid track record and has learned from past problems.

Lesson 5: Price it right

On top of the other missteps, the Xbox One cost $100 more than the PlayStation 4 on day one. That was largely because of the inclusion of Kinect, which wasn’t optional and didn’t enhance most games. Fans resented paying for a peripheral they didn’t want or need.

Xbox / Microsoft

This time around, Microsoft has priced its top-tier system at the same price as the PlayStation 5 and also has the cheapest next-gen console with the Xbox Series S. Combined with Game Pass and xCloud, that’s a compelling value proposition that has earned Xbox a lot of goodwill for its upcoming launch.

The Xbox Series X and Series S are also good overall value, given the price of their predecessors, the hardware inside, and the number of games available at launch. Microsoft is not alone here — the PlayStation 5 is also a good value. Still, a $500 Series X looks like a steal compared to the $500 Xbox One, or the Xbox One X, which sold for $400 (or as low as $300 on sale) until it was discontinued in early 2020.

Since we’re talking about Xbox, our best move would be to provide you with all Black Friday Xbox One deals, so that you can leverage the Black Friday discounts.

Chris Morris
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Chris Morris has covered consumer technology and the video game industry since 1996, offering analysis of news and trends and…
Xbox is testing a handheld device, but it’s a long ways off
Phil Spencer at the Bethesda roundtable.

Xbox CEO Phil Spencer confirmed that the company is working on a handheld device, which has been heavily rumored for quite some time. However, don't expect it any time soon.

In a Bloomberg interview, Spencer said Microsoft said that a potential device is only in the prototyping stage at this time. Even if the team was set to bring a product to market, it would still be a few years out.

Read more
From swamps to Appalachia, how South of Midnight captures a seldom-seen America
Hazel runs away from a giant crocodile in South of Midnight.

After a slow start to this console generation, Xbox is looking to make its mark starting in 2025. Major entries in franchises like Gears of War, Doom, and Fable are on the way, alongside an ambitious Perfect Dark revival. The most intriguing game in its lineup, though, isn’t a glitzy game from a pre-existing franchise; it’s something entirely new.

South of Midnight is the latest game from We Happy Few developer Compulsion games, and the studio’s first project since being acquired by Microsoft in 2018. The action-adventure project, set to launch in 2025, is unique in two key ways. For one, it has a unique visual style that makes it look like a playable stop-motion film. It’s also a video game set in a place that few big-budget games have ever deeply explored: America’s deep South. It’s a magical realist story inspired by Southern gothic literature and folktales from the region.

Read more
A classic platformer trilogy is coming to Xbox Game Pass tomorrow
Spyro flies off away from an attack with white mountains in the background.

After a little tease earlier today, Xbox quickly confirmed that the Spyro Reignited Trilogy is coming to Xbox Game Pass shortly. Best of all, it's hitting multiple tiers, including Game Pass Standard.

Spyro Reignited Trilogy includes Spyro the Dragon, Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage!, and Spyro: Year of the Dragon, and will be added to the subscription service on November 12 -- so, tomorrow. It'll be available on Game Pass Ultimate, PC Game Pass, and Game Pass Standard.

Read more