Skip to main content

It’s time for the Mario Sports games to go free-to-play

Every time a Mario sports game has launched in the past decade, it’s seemingly been the same story. Players get a strong core experience anchored by highly refined sports gameplay. The problem? There aren’t a lot of compelling reasons to actually play due to thin feature lists. We saw it in Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash, Mario Sports Superstars, Mario Golf: Super Rush, and now again in Mario Strikers: Battle League.

The latter is arguably the most egregious offender yet. While it features some of the most complex and nuanced Mario sports gameplay to date, it’s severely lacking when it comes to game modes. Rather than including challenges and minigames to test players’ skill, there are three options: Freeplay, a small set of tournaments, and online play. All of those can be enjoyed solo, but it very much feels like a multiplayer-first experience built around its standout online “club” mode.

Recommended Videos

It’s a hard sell for a $60 game, but the problem might just be the format. Out of all Nintendo’s series, the Mario sports games could benefit from a more modern approach by adopting a free-to-play model. The trickier part is making sure that’s done the right way.

Less is fine

What’s funny about a game like Mario Strikers: Battle League is that it has just about as much content as other modern titles. It’s not unusual for a multiplayer-focused game to launch with one tight mode and expand on it later with updates. We already know that Battle League will get DLC, bringing more characters to the roster. The difference between that game and something like Apex Legends comes down to the initial buy-in.

Bowser wearing Bushido Gear soccer gear.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Due to the nature of their $0 price tag, free-to-play games have much more flexibility than full retail ones. It doesn’t really matter how sparse the package is when players are downloading it for free. Successful free-to-play multiplayer games tend to hook players with an immediately fun experience upfront that feels like a steal and make their money later by selling bonuses (a tactic that some games tend to abuse).

By contrast, players expect a complete experience right out the gate if they’re paying full retail for a game — and that’s what Nintendo is currently struggling with. Recent Mario sports games (and even Nintendo Switch Sports) almost feel inspired by free-to-play design, putting more effort into creating strong online hooks that’ll keep players engaged. Extra content generally comes later, long after the average player will have moved on to the next hot game.

Take Mario Golf, for instance. Nintendo GameCube title Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour featured four primary solo modes, around a dozen multiplayer options, a handful of minigames, and unlockables for players to chase over the long-term. Last year’s Mario Golf: Super Rush launched as a much slimmer package with a quick story mode and three primary multiplayer options. It would add new features over time, but it was hard to shake the feeling that Nintendo missed the green with its release strategy.

A round of Battle Golf in Mario Golf: Super Rush.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If Nintendo is going to continue slimming down its multiplayer games in that way, a free-to-play pivot feels like a win-win move. It would allow the company to focus on creating strong multiplayer experiences that don’t need to launch with the wealth of content fans have come to expect from previous Mario sports titles or $60 games. Doing so would help games like Mario Strikers: Battle League find a broader audience that could be hooked into the game’s superior soccer systems through its club mode.

It would be an unprecedented move for Nintendo, but not for the industry at large. This month, both Knockout City and Fall Guys: Ultimate Knockout pivoted to a free-to-play model. Both games are excellent multiplayer titles that struggled to retain their audiences after being offered to players for free initially, but they sold in the long-term. The much bigger example is Halo Infinite, which went the free-to-play route with its multiplayer and sold its campaign separately. It continues to be a winning strategy for some of gaming’s most profitable franchises, so why shouldn’t Mario get in on the action too?

Nintendo’s cash cow

There’s an easy answer as to why Nintendo wouldn’t make a Mario game, sports or otherwise, free-to-play: They make too much money. Mario is a consistent cash cow for Nintendo, which can seemingly spin any game featuring the plumber into gold. If Nintendo did experiment with a free-to-play model, it would need to find a way to recoup what it would have made from simply launching a $60 game that it rarely ever discounts.

That’s where the downside of the business model comes into play. Free-to-play games have a bad rap with some players for their sometimes aggressive use of microtransactions. For every game that only charges for cosmetics, there’s another that veers uncomfortably close into pay-to-win territory, like Pokémon Unite.

Zirco Trading menu from Pokemon Unite
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Previous Nintendo attempts at free-to-play have been mixed when it comes to how successfully they’ve been monetized. There was the Wii U’s ill-fated Wii Sports Club, which charged users a daily fee to play. Other free Switch titles like Pokemon Quest and Super Kirby Clash haven’t exactly been big earners for Nintendo, though it’s found more success with Fire Emblem Heroes, a mobile game that employs “gacha” mechanics.

I imagine a free Mario sports game could charge players for new characters rather than giving them away for free, which seems reasonable, though there’s some potential danger too. Some Mario sports titles feature unlockable gear, like golf clubs, that can boost players’ stats. Locking those behind a paywall could be what cracks the thin ice the series is already standing on.

It’s risky, but a change of some form is in order. The Mario sports games have been in a steady decline since 2015 and Mario Strikers: Battle League’s lack of content is a troubling sign for the series’ future. A bold step into the free-to-play arena could allow Nintendo to stay competitive in a crowded modern scene and reclaim its position as the king of multiplayer.

Giovanni Colantonio
As Digital Trends' Senior Gaming Editor, Giovanni Colantonio oversees all things video games at Digital Trends. As a veteran…
PlayStation needs to embrace Nintendo as its next ally
PlayStation Portal and the switch on a table.

As the walls of exclusivity begin to crumble and development costs soar ever higher, PlayStation is looking to every possible market to grow. PCs were the first obvious target since they aren't generally considered a direct competitor to dedicated hardware and give PlayStation a way to entice those players into its own ecosystem. While there are still growing pains to work out there, specifically with the forced PSN accounts even for single-player games like God of War: Ragnarok, PlayStation has more to gain in its budding relationship with Nintendo hardware.

I imagine it was a harder pill to swallow given the history between these two companies, which is why it took so long. We've only seen one example so far, but PlayStation embracing the Switch (and eventual Switch successor) could end up being an even bigger boon to business than PC.
The best of both worlds
While I believe it is somewhat overblown about how similar PlayStation first-party games have been since The Last of Us, we can at least agree that the PS5 has a distinct lack of family-friendly games. After Sackboy: A Big Adventure at the system's launch and Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart not long after, first-party titles have been aimed squarely at older teens and adults.

Read more
Nintendo World Championships turned me into a Super Mario Bros. god
Box art for super mario bros shows fire Mario running.

The newly released Nintendo World Championships: NES Edition is all about mastery. The retro microgame collection takes 13 NES classics and breaks them down into bite-sized speedrunning challenges that beg players to replay them over and over to lower their best time. That process all leads to the package's big event, the titular Nintendo World Championships. Every week, players all submit their best times for five specific challenges and fight for a top ranking come Monday morning.

I had no idea how I'd fare against hundreds of thousands of people in the game's first week. While I'd been sharpening my skills during the review period for the game, I still didn't have much confidence that I could make a splash in games like Super Mario Bros. that have been mapped out to perfection already.

Read more
This is my favorite puzzle game of the year, and you can play it via Netflix
arranger impressions best puzzle games 2024 enemy

This has been a particularly great year for puzzle games. Lorelei and the Laser Eyes and the recent remake of Riven offer up some mind-bending puzzles to solve, while games like Isles of Sea and Sky and Mars After Midnight find an innovative gameplay conceit and explore the concept to its fullest. The latter type of puzzle game I described tends to be more appealing to me, and a new game launching this week checked off all the right boxes for me. Arranger: A Role-Puzzling Adventure from developer Furniture & Mattress is coming to PC, PlayStation, and Switch on July 25, but you can play it on mobile at no extra charge if you're a Netflix subscriber.

Arranger is a grid-based puzzle game where the world is made up of tiles, and players slide them around as they move. It's one of those genius gameplay concepts that has existed in bits and pieces in other games, but has never been explored to its fullest like this before. Arranger does just that while telling a coming-of-age story that emotionally ties back into that gameplay mechanic. It's my favorite puzzle game in a year that has already been outstanding for the genre, and a must-play for fans of the genre.
Putting the right pieces into place
Arranger creates the perfect setup for a game where players must arrange and move tiles. It's a coming-of-age story about a girl named Jemma who was abandoned and left to grow up in a village when she was younger. Unlike the people around her, she can see and move the world, which is split up into floor tiles. That causes issues. Everyone in her hometown seems to want her to leave, and she does so after accidentally awakening some static, a mysterious, controlling substance, in a cave right outside of town. Throughout Arranger, Jemma explores the outside world and learns more about her origins and why this static has overtaken the world.

Read more