After years of games like Final Fantasy X and Final Fantasy XIII, where the famed role-playing series does little more than lead its players by the nose down gaudy, linear paths to the next melodramatic dialogue scene, this final entry on the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 leaves the player to explore, to wander into the unknown and find answers for themselves.
Like the heroine it’s invested so much capital and time in over the past decade – Square Enix has been developing Lightning-starring Final Fantasy XIII games for ten years now, and the first of those alone cost $65 million to develop – the creators of Final Fantasy aren’t entirely sure where to go. There are new games on shelves and on the horizon in addition to Lightning Returns, but even those are the products of past work that are only now coming to fruition.
Final Fantasy XIV is a re-launch of a failed 2010 MMO. Final Fantasy XV, due out on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One in the near future, is actually just Final Fantasy Versus XIII, an aborted PlayStation 3 exclusive that went into development all the way back in 2006. Square Enix is desperately trying to figure out what the future of its signature series is, going so far as to form an internal team called the “Final Fantasy Committee.” This group of key creators is headed up by Yoshinori Kitase, current producer of the series and a writer/director whose history stretches back to the Super Nintendo’s Final Fantasy V.
“What defines Final Fantasy? It’s no specific word or phrase,” Kitase told Digital Trends in a recent interview conducted through a translator. “This has been brought up in meetings amongst the development team. We ask, ‘What is a Final Fantasy game? What do you think?’ One of the creators of the original Final Fantasy who has since left the company mentioned something cool that stuck in my mind: In order to create a Final Fantasy, you take the talent you have in your group [at] that moment and utilize their talents while maximizing the abilities of the hardware you’re developing the game on. That’s what Final Fantasy is.”
That original creator Kitase is so hesitant to mention is Hironobu Sakaguchi, who left Square Enix a decade ago to form the studio Mistwalker. The philosophy of pushing video game technology as far as possible with a game that expresses the individual talent working on it drove the Final Fantasy series for years. It’s why every entry was so wildly different from the next. The Kitase-helmed Final Fantasy VI was an opera about a human empire and a race of demigods at war being brought low by a lone madman. It was followed by the hugely popular Final Fantasy VII, a melodrama that traded the mystical setting and massive cast of VI for a small ensemble and science fiction. One pushed the art of pixels on the SNES, the next ushered in an era of polygons and full-motion video on PlayStation.
“What defines Final Fantasy? It’s no specific word or phrase.”
Infusing new blood, not just relying on an established team’s talents and technology, seems to be the third key to keeping Final Fantasy a thriving series. Sakaguchi got the series running, but it was letting upstarts like Kitase direct and write mainline entries in the mid-90s that allowed Final Fantasy to blossom. Even after the success of Final Fantasy X, another Kitase-led entry, the series evolved in surprising new directions under the lead of Yasumi Matsuno and Hiroyuki Ito, the two directors that made Final Fantasy XII. In the wake of Final Fantasy XIII, which disappointed many fans, Kitase recognized the need for new minds to helm the series.
“I give the creator the trust to tweak the game to their liking,” Kitase said of handing over the reins of Final Fantasy. “[Yuji] Abe was in charge of the battle system in the first Final Fantasy XIII but with Lightning Returns he was reassigned to being the game design director. I trusted Abe-san.”
“I give the creator the trust to tweak the game to their liking.”
It’s because of Abe that Lightning Returns feels so open and adventurous compared to the other Final Fantasy games that came out over the past seven years. Abe actually started his tenure at Square Enix working alongside Tetsuya Nomura, director of Final Fantasy XV, on Kingdom Hearts II. He had high hopes for the battle system he created for Final Fantasy XIII but was disappointed when fans were divided on it. He realized the problem was a lack of cohesion between the battle system and the game world itself, something that also seems to be an essential element in making a true Final Fantasy game.
“When I first tackled Lightning Returns, the request was to give it the feel of an entirely new game,” Abe told Digital Trends. “Staying within the series, but a whole new title. There were many times I had to ask myself, ‘Is it okay to do something like this?’ My seniors, though, would encourage me to try something new, something different. In Final Fantasy XIII, I was in charge of the battle system but the map and world design was handled by someone else. With me handling both elements in Lightning Returns, I think you’ll have a very different impression of how the game plays.”
While Abe’s influence certainly gives Lightning Returns a distinct flavor, and in turn helps the Final Fantasy series regain some of its identity, there are factors beyond just game design influencing how Square Enix will create future entries in the series. Until this past generation, Final Fantasy was rigidly defined by the console technology cycle. “Before the PS2, it would be about two years to make one game,” Kitase recalls. Sometimes it took even less. Final Fantasy VI, for example, was created in just over one year. “So considering that the lifecycle of a console was about five or six years, if you simply divide you end up with three games over that period. Moving into the current generation of consoles, the development process became more involved and [had] a lot of costs associated with it. We weren’t developing like we would have on previous console generations.”
The demands of modern game development affects the nature of the actual game content. Final Fantasy XIII, for example, buried scads of expository information in its menu systems rather than actually explaining things in a more natural way. The entire world and its history were never explained in dialogue, but only in big blocks of text that most players would never see. Final Fantasy XIII-2 went a long way toward addressing the narrative and gameplay failings of its predecessor, but the need to complete the game within 18 months forced the team to leave out chunks of the story. That story was reserved as supplemental material and released as downloadable content months after the game. Final Fantasy XIII-2 was, in effect, released as an incomplete game, its ending purchased after the fact. The team promises that Lightning Returns is the complete package, but Abe acknowledged that no matter what shape the next Final Fantasy game takes, it will have to be backed by similar supplementary material.
“It’s an inevitable result of how consoles have evolved,” said Abe. “With each generation, you increase processing abilities as well as how much content you can deliver, as we did on a disc. Even with the next generation, there’s going to be more advancement beyond what we have now. When you’re thinking about the fact that you can do so much, and you can fit so much more game into one unit, of course you want to put in more content so you come up with even more ideas to present the world of a game. Unfortunately, though, with those new specs come new costs. There are going to be times when you want to put something in the main game and the cost just prevents it. That’s where these expansions come in. You have to supplement that main game to get in all that background information you want.”
One thing that everyone working with Final Fantasy agrees on is the need to finish games quicker. The corporate culture at Square Enix has been trying to push for shorter development times for years now. Yoichi Wada, Square Enix’s former CEO who resigned in the spring of 2013, said all the way back in 2009 that “it takes us too long to finish a game.” Keeping development times shorter going forward will do more for the team than simply keep a product in front of customers. It will also keep the developers themselves creatively sharp.
“With a shorter production time, it’s easier to maintain motivation, you keep interest in the title,” explained Abe, “That tends to produce a better game. With longer developments, you move forward and finish part of the game, but then realize you want to go back and tweak the beginning. That causes a delay, and it also creates fatigue when you’re just plugging along. We have been working on Final Fantasy XIII over a 10-year span. The teams that worked on this series for the most part, including myself, were working on Final Fantasy for the very first time. To keep the motivation and passion burning is definitely a challenge.”
As of this writing, the door is closing on Final Fantasy XIII. While the game won’t be out in the U.S. or Europe for a few more months, Lightning Returns hit Japanese consoles on November 21. Now Kitase and his committee can get to work plotting just what form Final Fantasy XVI and beyond will take. Yuji Abe has the experience to move forward with his team and potentially make one of those new chapters in the quarter-century old series.
“When I first started working on Lightning Returns, I told the staff this game was a test case for another game that I eventually want to make for myself, a game that I would love to make,” said Abe, “In going through the process of making Lightning Returns, I feel that I was able to gain experience and knowledge on how to ultimately make that dream game. I’m not sure what form it will take or if the company will even approve it, but that’s what I want.”
