Skip to main content

Xbox Game Pass is killing pre-orders — and that’s a good thing

A recent survey on Windows Central polled readers on their pre-order plans for Halo Infinite. Out of nearly 300 responses, two-thirds said they didn’t plan to pre-order the game. However, nearly half the respondents said that they planned to play the game on Xbox Game Pass, and multiple respondents who pre-ordered the game said they planned to play it on Game Pass, too.

Game Pass is helping lead the charge to kill pre-orders. Although that may not be a good thing for retailers and publishers, it’s great for gamers — especially as more titles ship in broken states after suffering delays. Although pre-orders will inevitably stick around for a while, they’re becoming obsolete, and Game Pass is a driving force behind that.

Pre-orders are bad for the people who matter

Battlefield 2042 Pre-Order
Image used with permission by copyright holder

I don’t want to disparage the role retailers play in game sales. All told, retailers have played a critical part in preserving physical video games in this mostly digital era. However, pre-orders only benefit retailers and publishers, not players. And as someone who’s been bitten by pre-order issues more than once, I will always side with the players.

Ever since the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, retailers and publishers have found new ways to incentivize pre-orders. In most cases, that comes in the form of an extra skin or some other cosmetic pre-order bonus. Now, with digital sales easier than ever on recent hardware, some publishers have resorted to offering early access to games (take the recent Persona 5 Strikers or upcoming Battlefield 2042, for example).

Instead of rewarding good video games, the pre-order system rewards good marketing. Last year, it was Cyberpunk 2077, but there are dozens of other examples of broken games that took advantage of large pre-order numbers. Once the pre-order is secured, it doesn’t really matter how the game ships. You’ve spent the money, and that’s what matters to retailers and publishers.

The pre-order system is already antiquated and obsolete, but players are still willing to put down money on hotly anticipated games. With a program like Game Pass, players don’t need to worry about that. It works alongside the marketing hype, not as a means to exploit it. Game Pass helps players judge games as they are, not as they could be. And it reaches beyond just Xbox.

Game Pass is bigger than Xbox

Stream from Xbox Game Pass Android
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Although Game Pass on Xbox is the best version, the program is much larger than a single console. It works on PC, too, and Microsoft now offers console-free gaming through cloud streaming. Although we aren’t getting Game Pass on Switch or PlayStation 5, the program still covers two major platforms for playing video games, as well as a quickly emerging one.

I’m mainly a PC gamer, and Game Pass for PC has saved my pre-order dollars more than once. I planned on pre-ordering Outriders ahead of launch, but I waited after hearing that it was launching on Game Pass. The ended up being a good call; the game launched in a broken state that made online co-op nearly impossible.

Similarly, 12 Minutes was one of my most anticipated games of 2021, but I found it tedious and unimaginative after a few hours of playing (though our own Otto Kratky would disagree). This point isn’t to sing the praise of Game Pass, but rather to show the benefits of a pre-order-free way to play games.

I would have pre-ordered both of those games and been disappointed. Game Pass is the only platform doing day-one releases at the moment, but a world where gamers can move beyond pre-orders is good for everyone. Game Pass is already on Xbox, PC, and mobile, and there remains a power vacuum on Switch and PlayStation 5.

Halo Infinite is a sign of the times

New spartan armor in Halo Infinite.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Getting back to Halo Infinite, it’s hard to ignore the elephant in the room — the disastrous campaign demo from 2020. Although half of survey respondents said they planned to play on Game Pass, there are likely some people who saw the messy state of the game last year and decided it just wasn’t for them.

Imagine now if Microsoft showed off an “in-engine” demo with all the sliders cranked to max and a neat vertical slice that only showed the game’s best qualities. In this darkest scenario, Halo Infinite would already be on store shelves, pre-orders would likely have gone through the roof, and players would be left disappointed.

This exercise shows how games are marketed and released in 2021. Marketing hype plays a critical role in selling the experience before games launch, and even the slightest sign that a game isn’t finished is enough to turn players away. From the Watch Dogs E3 demo to the countless Cyberpunk 2077 showcases, game publishers have set a bar that they can’t feasibly meet.

Game Pass — and hopefully future programs like it — removes that process from the equation. It doesn’t eliminate the marketing hype around video games, but it helps rein in how that marketing translates into sales, especially ahead of launch.

More to come

Windows 11 Xbox Games Pass
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Pre-orders aren’t dead — and they likely won’t be for many years. There’s value in picking up a Steelbook for a game you’re looking forward to or securing an extra skin that only a small group can access. And for big budget first-party games on the Sony side of things, pre-orders are usually a safe bet.

Third-party releases and first-party titles that have yet to prove themselves are a different matter. Microsoft is tackling that issue head-on with Game Pass. Hopefully, others will join before too long.

Jacob Roach
Lead Reporter, PC Hardware
Jacob Roach is the lead reporter for PC hardware at Digital Trends. In addition to covering the latest PC components, from…
Black Ops 6 might be the biggest Call of Duty release ever
Soldiers near a train in Black Ops 6.

Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 is on track to be the most successful Call of Duty release in the franchise's history thanks to a record-breaking launch, according to Activision and Microsoft.

The companies revealed that Black Ops 6 had the biggest three-day opening for the series by many metrics. It had the most players, most hours played, and the most total matches, according to a post on X (formerly Twitter). The game also got a shout-out during Microsoft's quarterly earnings call on Wednesday.

Read more
3 new Xbox Game Pass games to play this weekend (October 25-27)
A player holds a dead player as a body shield in Call of Duty: Black Ops 6.

It's Call of Duty week on Xbox Game Pass. Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 launched today, and from day one, it's a part of Game Pass Ultimate's game catalog. It's one of the big payoffs of Microsoft's $69 billion acquisition of Activision Blizzard. Depending on how it performs, it may be one of the most important games to ever come to the subscription service. On top of that, other Call of Duty games finally got Xbox Cloud Gaming support, which required collaboration with Ubisoft because of certain concessions made during the Activision Blizzard acquisition process. If you're an Xbox Game Pass Ultimate subscriber wondering what you should play this weekend, the obvious answer is Call of Duty.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 6
Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 - Global Launch Gameplay Trailer

After four years, the Call of Duty: Black Ops series has made its grand return. It brings the series' story to the 1990s with a spy-movie-like campaign that sees players investigate a secret, nefarious organization that has infiltrated the American government. While the campaign alone is reason enough to check out the new Call of Duty on Xbox Game Pass, Black Ops 6 also features meaty multiplayer and Zombies modes. Multiplayer is as exhilarating as ever, with an emphasis being placed on an "omnimovement" system that allows players to dive, roll, and dodge enemies with a lot more freedom than they could before. Meanwhile, Zombies mode finds a solid balance between old and new mechanics. Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 is available via PC, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, and Xbox Cloud Gaming with a Game Pass Ultimate subscription. It's also on PS4 and PS5.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III technically came to the subscription service in July but was restricted to PC and console play. Now, alongside Call of Duty: Black Ops 6, Modern Warfare III is playable via Xbox Cloud Gaming for Game Pass Ultimate subscribers. This was a lesser entry in the series with a disappointing campaign, but if you're looking for another premium Call of Duty game to try after playing lots of Black Ops 6, Modern Warfare III is the only other one on the service. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III is available to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate subscribers across PC, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, and Xbox Cloud Gaming. It's also on PS4 and PS5.
Call of Duty: Warzone
Finally, Call of Duty: Warzone also comes to Xbox Cloud Gaming today. This free-to-play battle royale title doesn't require any sort of subscription to play normally, but Game Pass subscribers now have the benefit of not needing to be tethered down by specific hardware. So far, there aren't any other additional in-game perks for Game Pass subscribers, but hopefully Warzone will follow Overwatch 2's lead and add some soon enough. If you aren't using Xbox Cloud Gaming, Call of Duty: Warzone is playable on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S.

Read more
3 new Xbox Game Pass games to try this weekend (October 18-20)
South Park The Fractured But Whole

While the first half of October was fairly light on new Xbox Game Pass additions, the back half of the month is a lot more exciting. Of course, Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 is the month's biggest release, but that's still a week away. Meanwhile, this week saw two great RPGs and an excellent indie game hit Microsoft's subscription service. If you're wondering what you should be playing this weekend, all three of these new Xbox Game Pass additions are worthy of your time.
South Park: The Fractured But Whole
South Park: The Fractured But Whole Gameplay Trailer - Gamescom 2016

While this year's South Park: Snow Day was a disappointment, the two Ubisoft-published games that preceded it narratively are stellar. One of those, the superhero-themed South Park: The Fractured But Whole, just came to Xbox Game Pass. This game perfectly captures the handcrafted look of the show with its art and the franchise's crass humor through its increasingly ridiculous story about Cartman, a new kid, and their other friends pretending to be superheroes. It's a surprisingly well-made grid-based tactical RPG, making it a significantly better game than it may seem on the surface.

Read more