Skip to main content

So close, but so far: New Apple TV is still steps away from Jobs’ ultimate vision

new apple tv strives for steve jobs ultimate vision comes up short so close  but far still steps away from
Image used with permission by copyright holder
There may be a reason Apple named its set-top box simply Apple TV. Perhaps in 2007 when the first Apple TV debuted, the name symbolized Apple’s hope that it would one day achieve the Holy Grail of TV that Steve Jobs envisioned before his death: Syncing all of your media devices “over the simplest interface you could imagine.”

It’s been a long wait for the new Apple TV to arrive (two and a half years to be exact), and a lot longer since Jobs first uttered those words. But, from what we saw at Apple’s special event in San Francisco, the shiny new box that Apple debuted today appears to come tantalizingly close to realizing his dream.

The touch, the feel of Apple

When it comes to the user experience, Apple’s iPhone and iPad have created an intimacy between user and content that makes navigation second nature. We slide, touch, and expand our fingers along smooth glass, and the device reacts in kind. But that experience hasn’t translated to the largest screen in the house. The new Apple TV aims to do just that, starting with the remote.

Apple-TV-2015-touch_surface_remote_large
Image used with permission by copyright holder

With a thumb-operated touch pad up top and scarce buttons, the new remote presents a design that’s forehead-slappingly simple. It uses Bluetooth 4.0 so you don’t need line-of-sight, offers a Lightning connection with a rechargeable battery that runs up to 3 months per charge, and will control A/V receivers and other devices over CEC (consumer electronics communication). The device also doubles as a gaming controller, and multi-player games will let users connect with an iPhone or iPod touch — no Androids allowed for now.

The box runs tvOS, a new operating system closely related to iOS 9, allowing for cross-platform development. That shared blood means you can do things like start a game on your phone and finish it at home. More noticeably, the interface has been cleaned up with sleek 3D-style icons that allow you to move them around with your thumb, a broad search screen that will tell you where to find content, and gorgeous screensavers with HD video.

More powerful, and more capable search … for iTunes anyway

Aside from the futuristic, pie-in-the-sky TV experience Jobs always wanted, the Apple TV needed some decent voice-automated search just to keep up with rivals like Roku 3 and the Amazon Fire TV — Siri to the rescue! For now, the voice attendant is integrated into Netflix, Hulu, HBO, and of course, iTunes.

Apple’s grand vision of the future relies on your total immersion in the Apple universe.

During the presentation we saw Siri do some pretty cool things, not the least of which was backing up 15 seconds and temporarily turning on captions when the presenter asked “Siri, what did she say?” Siri also pulled off other tricks like finding the moment when Edward Norton shows up in a Modern Family episode. Siri can also find just the newest family movies, for instance, or dig deep into subsections to search by director, date, cast, and even age rating. The device’s new A8 processor seemed to make that process extremely quick, though we’ll have to wait to see if the $150 Apple TV can smoke streaming peers that run just $100

Siri support will quickly and easily navigate to the most minute of choices available on iTunes, if it works as flawlessly as it did on stage. But what about third-party apps? We doubt an Amazon app will allow for such powerful search parameters across platforms, for instance, but we can imagine Netflix bowing to Apple’s developers, which could offer a luxurious way to get through Big Red’s massive vault of content. Unfortunately, for now we just don’t know how well Siri search will work outside of iTunes.

Apps, apps, and more apps

“The Future of TV is apps,” Tim Cook said as the Apple TV presentation began. To that end, Apple put tvOS in the hands of 11 million developers, and we expect to see some impressive new efforts that will help close the gap between your mobile devices and your big screen at home, creating a singular entertainment experience.

The new Major League Baseball app from MLB.com makes an impressive first step. It offers a host of live games streaming at 60 frames per second in HD — if you’ve ponied up the $130 yearly subscription fee, that is. The system showed just how impressive streaming live sports could be, allowing users to call up games, go dual-screen, and even check out stats, all with the swipe of a thumb.

The appearance of Apple Music is another stride toward Jobs’ vision. When the new service premiered last June, it offered an unprecedented level of integration for users who bought in, allowing you to upload every song you’ve ever collected, burned, or downloaded to sit side by side with music on your phone or tablet, and 30 million songs on demand. Now that Apple Music is on the Apple TV, the system has come full circle, allowing you to access all of your music in the cloud, without the need for AirPlay, hard drives, or even your iPhone.

Like everything else Apple makes, however, Apple’s grand vision of the future relies on your total immersion in the Apple universe. As long as you don’t deviate from that little Apple icon, all of your devices can now sync effortlessly together, putting your music, streaming media, and mobile video games in a single, infinite loop that follows you everywhere.

The elephant in San Francisco

Despite new features, cross-platform apps, and an Apple-intuitive interface, there’s still one thing missing to fulfill Jobs’ vision: live TV. Apple may believe that the future of TV is apps, but until those apps contain live sports, local broadcasts, news, and other events, viewers will still demand broadcasts, and Apple TV doesn’t touch them.

There’s still one thing missing to fulfill Jobs’ vision: live TV.

It’s well known that Apple has been working on its own Internet TV service to deliver just that for some time now. Back in 2014, Apple attempted to forge a partnership with Comcast to make the new service a reality, but that partnership quickly folded, and Apple has gone it alone from there.

But shaking hands with thousands of affiliates is an unprecedented mess of a project. Some reports also suggest that several networks are playing hardball on price: Apple wants to offer its new service for $40 a month, and the networks want more revenue.

At any rate, the service is expected to be pushed back to 2016.

Considering the new iPhone shoots 4K video, it also seems like a notable omission that the new Apple TV doesn’t stream 4K content. That said, it’s probably a savvy move by Apple — 4K content is still woefully lacking, and what’s more, it’s unlikely customers of Apple’s affordable streaming box are early-adopters of 4K TVs. Give Apple two years for the content to arrive, and you can bet we’ll see another generation upgrade.

All told, Apple’s new device is an enticing new addition to the field. We’ll have to wait until we get our hands on one, but the device should stack up well with flagship devices from Roku and Amazon, and hopefully best them. Moreover, the new Apple TV is achingly close to accomplishing Steve Jobs’ ultimate vision. Perhaps the next generation will finally turn that page.

Ryan Waniata
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Waniata is a multi-year veteran of the digital media industry, a lover of all things tech, audio, and TV, and a…
This smart 4K projector is nearly half-price in Walmart’s sale
The Wimius smart 4K projector on a desk.

If you've been thinking about installing a projector in your living room to create a cinematic experience, you won't want to miss this offer from Walmart. The Wimius smart 4K projector, which is originally priced at $360, is down by nearly half to only $190, for huge savings of $170. We're not sure how much time is remaining before this bargain ends though, so if you're interested, we highly recommend completing your purchase as soon as possible.

Why you should buy the Wimius smart 4K projector
Setting up a home theater projector is an excellent way to create a movie theater vibe at home, and you won't have to spend hundreds of dollars if you go for the Wimius smart 4K projector. Its projection size ranges from 50 inches to as large as 300 inches, so if you've got a big enough wall or projection screen, it will really be like you're watching movies at the cinema. The projector is capable of 4K Ultra HD resolution, and it has an extremely long lamp life of 200,000 hours so it will be a long time before you need to replace its bulb. It also offers auto focus and keystone correction technology for even better visuals.

Read more
These Sony OTC hearing aids offer optimized audio and all-day comfort
Man wearing Sony CRE-C10 OTC hearing aids.

There's a lot to be said about OTC or over-the-counter hearing aids. They're more accessible, usually because they're more affordable, and you don't need a prescription to get some. That's precisely why they're called "over-the-counter." Of course, they're really meant for mild to medium hearing loss, however. If you experience severe hearing loss you'll need to go to your local physician, as you might expect. But also one of the great things about this relatively new, untapped category of sound devices is that there are a lot of great options from brands you wouldn't expect. Take Sony, for instance, which has several OTC hearing aid options, and they're available at Best Buy of all places.

You can walk in, off the street, and walk out with them same-day, or buy them online and have them shipped to your house. How's that for excellent service and accessibility? But if you need a quick introduction to some of Sony's best OTC hearing aid options, we've got you covered.

Read more
Now is the time to get the best noise-canceling headphones
The Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones in Diamond color resting against a headphones stand.

Noise-canceling headphones' performance has been pushed with each passing product release, and the crown regularly passes between between Bose, Sony, and Apple as they attempt to one-up each other. Currently, Bose stands above the rest with the QuietComfort Ultra Headphones -- and right now they're $100 off until December 2.

What is it the Bose do so well? To start off, they offer the best noise-canceling performance available from a pair of headphones. In his review, Simon Cohen found that "The QC Ultra provide impressive levels of hush in a variety of scenarios." You can still get slightly better isolation with the Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds or Sony WF-1000XM5 earbuds, but for most of us, having something in your ear for a long flight gets uncomfortable pretty fast. Plus, there's the worry an earbud will fall out (I find the fit on the Sony earbuds in particular doesn't always feel very secure).

Read more