Long Island couple sues over copyrighted mansion design

By Lulu Chang July 9, 2016

courtroom ai attorney — Creative Commons

Just how much are your dreams worth? If they manifest themselves in the form of a mansion, quite a bit, it would seem. After a neighbor copied the design of one Long Island couple’s dream home in the Nassau County village of Lawrence, Seth and Rivka Fortgang filed a lawsuit to protect their design. The house itself is valued at $1.48 million, and Rivka Fortgang copyrighted the architectural plans (because apparently, she knew something like this would happen).

BUILD YOUR OWN: Long Island couple sues neighbors for copying their mansion https://t.co/KW59ZTXO5G pic.twitter.com/pevWEYnfnJ

— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) July 7, 2016

According to the lawsuit, which was filed in Long Island Federal Court, the neighbors actually requested the copyrighted plans from the Village of Lawrence Building Department. After hearing of this development and noticing the construction of an eerily similar house taking form in nearby Cedarhurst, the Fortgangs reached out to their lawyers.

But the neighbors, Daniella and Ari Schwartz, insist they are doing nothing wrong. Their lawyer, Daniel Schloss, has noted in court documents that there is nothing so unique about the Fortgangs’ home that it would be protected by the Copyright Act.

“We note that the exterior façade of the Fortgang residence consists of several windows, rather generic gables, and entry way doors,” Schloss said. “However in the interests of professional courtesy, our clients have agreed to temporarily postpone construction of the present design … pending certain changes and amendments to its exterior façade elements,” he added.

But if you think the story ends there, think again. According to the lawsuit, Rivka Fortgang, an exterior and interior designer in her own right, has suffered “substantial damage to her reputation and her business in the upscale Five Towns community as a result of the copying,” the New York Daily News reports.

Neither the Fortgangs nor their lawyers have responded to requests for comment.

So watch out, prospective home builders. If you’re not a proponent of the notion that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, you may want to look into copyrighting your own designs sometime soon.

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…

Smart Home

The 5 best office chairs for long hours in 2024

The Verve in an office.

When you spend half (or more) of your day in an office chair, a $50 budget-buy store brand isn’t the kind of purchase you should be making. Not only are these cheap items more likely to break down over time, but there’s a good chance this kind of chair isn’t going to have the elevated support features your body needs. That’s why we’ve put together this list of the five best office chairs for long hours in 2024.

Each of these models are tailor-made for those of us who need a comfortable chair that feels good all day. We’ve also made sure to include a couple of options for folks who experience back pain, shoulder strain, and other sore conditions.

Smart Home

Matter gains support for kitchen appliances, adds new energy-tracking features

Matter received its big 1.2 update in late 2023, and now the Connectivity Standards Alliance (CSA) is ready to officially roll out Matter 1.3. The latest version of the interoperability standard is now available for use, offering added support for appliances like microwave ovens and lclothes dryers, while also introducing new features for water and energy management.

The full list of new device types supported by Matter 1.3 include microwave ovens, ovens, cooktops, extractor hoods (such as vent hoods), and laundry dryers. These aren't quite as exciting or mainstream as the nine device types introduced with Matter 1.2, but it's great to see the CSA continuing to broaden the reach of the Matter network.

Smart Home

Best Ring deals: Save on Ring doorbell and Ring alarm bundles

Ring Video Doorbell 3

Ring is probably one of the most well-known brands and one of the best video doorbell brands on the market, so it would make sense if you want to get yourself a Ring camera, especially if you're in the Amazon ecosystem. Luckily, there are a lot of options out there, whether you want a doorbell or a floodlight, and while not all of them have deals, you can always find something refurbished or in a bundle that should save you a bit of cash. That's why we've gone out and collected the best deals we could find for various Ring product and collected them below.
Ring Stick Up Cam Battery (refurbished) -- $58, was $90

The Ring Stick Up is a good security camera for indoors or outdoors. It can go almost anywhere, and allows you to hear and speak to people on camera from your phone or tablet. You can customize the motion sensors to focus on specific areas of your home, and it has a Live View that allows you to watch over your home in 1080p Full HD resolution at any time. It even works with Alexa, allowing you to hear audio announcements when motion is detected. The Ring Stick Up sets up in minutes and it charges easily with a removable battery pack. This is a great option if you’re looking for something capable but versatile.