Skip to main content

Judge Dismisses Some Damage Claims Against YouTube for Int’l Video

Judge Dismisses Some Damage Claims Against YouTube for Int

U.S. District Judge Louis Stanton has dismissed some damage claims in a class action copyright infringement lawsuit against YouTube and Google led by The Football Association Premier League, ruling the copyright holders of foreign works can’t sue Google for punitive damages arising from those materials’ distribution on YouTube—unless those works are registered for copyright in the United States. However, the judge did rule that if the the copyright holder prevail in their infringement suit, they could seek punitive damages for live broadcasts distributed via YouTube, under a “live broadcast exemption” in U.S. copyright law.

The plaintiffs, representing a group of international sports and music copyright holders, had argued foreign works were exempt from the U.S. Copyright Act’s registration requirement. The judge’s ruling does not exempt the plaintiffs from seeking statutory damages, if they should prevail at trial. However, save in the case of live broadcasts, they may not seek punitive damages. The upshot to Google, if it is found guilty of infringement, could be huge: the plaintiff’s recovery could reach into the billions of dollars if they win their case; punitive damages could easily double or triple that amount.

Recommended Videos

Google has consistently maintained the infringement claims are without merit.

Judge Stanton’s ruling reenforces an earlier ruling he made in Viacom’s $1 billion copyright infringement suit against Google and YouTube. Both suits were filed in 2007, and have have their discovery phases consolidated. In March, Stanton ruled Viacom couldn’t seek common law punitive damages against Google, because they aren’t available under the Copyright Act.

The Football Association Premier League’s suit seeks $1.65 billion in damages.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Early Black Friday fitness deals: Fitness trackers, exercise equipment up to 51% off
A woman works out in her home on the NordicTrack AirGlide elliptical.

Update 11/6/24: Though this is our first iteration of such a list for the 2024 Black Friday season, we're already quite happy with it. Apple showed up with an affordable Apple Watch (which has fitness tracking that, though on the simpler side, we actually like better than some of its more complex siblings) and the Peloton Guide is $100 off. Plus, we were able to find smart tracking in stationary scale format for just $23, an entry-level price anybody can afford. This is a great start and we're excited to see what is to come...

Despite lingering stereotypes, the tech space and fitness space are quite closely related. And so, for this Black Friday season, we know you may be interested in some great fitness gear. Luckily, while Black Friday officially starts on November 29, you can go ahead and get started on your fitness resolutions way early with early Black Friday deals. That means that if the early Black Friday headphones deal you picked up happens to be a good pair of running headphones, now is a fantastic time to pick up an exercise bike or treadmill. Alternatively, now is also a great time to pick up an excellent fitness tracker with early Black Friday smartwatch deals. No matter what your goals, however, the following deals are ripe and ready now, not in a few weeks, so there is no reason to delay your plans.
Renpho Smart Scale — $23 $29 21% off

Read more
Early Black Friday e-bike deals: 75% off folding, fat-tire, more
Two people putting on helmets getting ready to ride Lectric XP 3.0 folding e-bikes.

Update 11/07/24: You don't have to wait for Black Friday if you want to score a discount on an e-bike because we've already found some amazing early Black Friday e-bike deals. There's a chance that these prices go even lower during the shopping event, but we won't blame you if you're already tempted by these attractive offers.

More people are finding out that e-bikes for commuting is a transit cheat code, as their electric motors give the punch that you need to move faster and conquer uphill roads easier -- which is why we think there's going to be high demand for these personal transportation devices on Black Friday. Lucky for you, there's no need to wait until the shopping event officially starts on November 29 to buy one with huge savings because we've found these fantastic early Black Friday e-bike deals.

Read more
BLUETTI’s latest Elite 200 V2 portable power station gets a discount for launch
BLUETTI Elite 200 V2 portable power station deal -- hero

Typically, when a new launch happens you don't see a significant discount for a while, and for good reason. But perhaps because it's so close to Black Friday and the holiday discounts, BLUETTI just dropped a new release and an incredible deal. The brand-spanking-new Elite 200 V2 is $900 off the regular price. That means you can take home the Elite 200 V2, a 2073.6-watt-hour portable power station, for $1,099, instead of $1,999. That discount is good until December 3rd, so don't wait around if you need one. With another storm brewing off the coast of Florida, now's a good time to get a backup power solution if you don't already have one.

 
Save $900 on Bluetti's latest Elite 200 V2 portable power station

Read more