Skip to main content

Legal arguments pan, praise Google’s book deal

Legal arguments pan, praise Google

Microsoft Corp., Yahoo Inc. and a prominent antitrust lawyer urged a federal judge Tuesday to block a class-action settlement that would give Google Inc. the digital rights to a vast library of books.

As that coalition warned of a literary cartel that would lead to higher prices and less competition, Sony Electronics, a technology trade group and economics professors came to Google’s defense by depicting the book deal as a breakthrough that would make millions of hard-to-find books available to anyone on the Internet.

Tuesday’s legal sparring came on the deadline for written arguments about a $125 million settlement that would entrust Google with a digital database containing millions of copyright-protected books, including titles no longer being published.

But at least one more key document is expected before U.S. District Judge Denny Chin holds an Oct. 7 hearing in New York to review the settlement. The Justice Department has until Sept. 18 to file its brief, which may provide some inkling on whether antitrust regulators have determined if the deal would hurt competition.

The settlement, reached last October, has raised the specter of Google becoming even more powerful than it already has become as the owner of the Internet’s most popular search and most lucrative advertising network.

Those concerns represented the crux of a 32-page brief written by Silicon Valley attorney Gary Reback, who helped the Justice Department pursue an antitrust case against Microsoft’s bundling of personal computer software in the 1990s.

Reback filed the brief Tuesday on behalf of the Open Book Alliance, which includes Microsoft, Yahoo, Internet bookseller Amazon.com Inc., other companies and nonprofit organizations. Microsoft and Yahoo, which compete with Google in search, also filed separate arguments; Amazon submitted its protest last week.

The alliance contends Google conspired with the author and publishing groups that sued the Mountain View-based company to make it more difficult for competitors to create similar indexes of digital books. The alliance contends that competitive barriers would empower Google, authors and publishers to the raise prices of digital books well above the current standard of about $10 per volume.

"The publishing industry desperately wants to raise the retail price point for digital books," Reback wrote for the alliance. "The book settlement permits them to achieve that by working with Google."

Google would give 63 percent of its digital book sales to the participating authors and publishers. The settlement covers books under U.S. copyright through Jan. 5, 2009, unless the copyright owners decline to join the agreement.

Backers of the book deal — including 32 professors specializing in antitrust and economics law — contend the antitrust concerns are unfounded.

The Computer Communications Industry Association, a trade association critical of Microsoft during its antitrust case in the 1990s, argued that Google’s nonexclusive agreement won’t prevent other merchants from selling electronic books — if they can spend an estimated $100 million to enter the e-book market.

If anything, lawyers for Sony Corp.’s electronics division argued, the increased supply of books available through Google’s digital library would foster more innovation and lower prices for electronic readers, including Sony’s own.

As more people buy readers, more companies would have an incentive to sell digital books, Sony reasoned, noting that DVD players that once cost more than $1,000 now sell for as little as $50.

The misgivings about Google’s settlement extend beyond its potential effects on the digital book market.

Microsoft and Yahoo, in particular, are worried that Google’s expanded index of digital books would cause even more people to use its search engine, which already fields nearly two-thirds of U.S. search requests.

Getting more data about users preferences could help Google further improve its search engine and make competing even tougher for Microsoft and Yahoo, the companies warned. Redmond, Wash.-based Microsoft and Sunnyvale, Calif.-based Yahoo recently agreed to a 10-year partnership partly to have a larger set of data to improve search.

Google also might gain insights into the books that people are reading, something that prompted to a group of authors and publisher represented by the American Civil Liberties Union and the Electronic Frontier Foundation to object to the settlement.

Hoping to ease privacy concerns, Google is drawing up a separate policy governing the information it gets from book searches and sales.

Google also has made a series of concessions to address concerns by the settlement’s critics in Europe. Among other things, the company is adding two foreign representatives to the board overseeing its digital book rights. The governments of both Germany and France have filed objections to the U.S. book settlement.

Digital Trends Staff
Digital Trends has a simple mission: to help readers easily understand how tech affects the way they live. We are your…
Should you buy a new smart lock or retrofit your existing deadbolt?
Schlage Encode Plus smart lock installed on a wooden door to a living room.

When it comes to smart locks, all models essentially fall into two categories. The first category will be familiar to most people, as these are traditional smart locks built to replace your existing deadbolt. That means you'll get a whole new set of keys for your front door, as well as hardware that introduces smart features to your home.

The second kind of smart lock is a retrofit smart lock. These quirky devices are designed to fit over your existing hardware -- allowing you to keep using your old keys while also adding smart features. Both types of smart locks are great ways to upgrade your front door, but which is best for your home? Here's a closer look to help you decide if you should replace your traditional deadbolt with a smart lock or install a retrofit smart lock instead.
Consider your DIY skills

Read more
Best air fryer deals: As cheap as $25
The Costway 16-in-1 15-quart air fryer oven on a table with plates of food spread out around it.

Air fryers are probably some of the best smart kitchen appliances because they not only make frying a lot easier but can also keep you much healthier in the long run compared to a deep fryer. Some of the best air fryers on the market have a ton of great features, giving you the variety of doing things like rotisserie or even having dual baskets to fry two things at a time. So, if you're looking to grab yourself an air fryer, you may want to check out these air fryer deals; they're some of our favorites that we've collected from around the internet.
Bella Pro Series 4-quart digital air fryer — $40, was $70

The Bella Pro Series 4-quart digital air fryer is equipped with a 1,500-watt heating system with an adjustable cooking temperature of up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, which you can adjust through its digital touchscreen that also offers several preset cook modes. The air fryer offers enough capacity to cook meals for about four to six people, so it’s perfect for small families and intimate gatherings. The Bella Pro Series 4-quart digital air fryer also features a 60-minute automatic shut-off timer and a dishwasher-safe basket.

Read more
Best Instant Pot deals: Pressure cookers, air fryers and grills on sale
A stew cooks in the Instant Pot Precision electric Dutch Oven.

Instant Pot is such a widespread brand that if you've ever owned an air fryer, pressure cooker, or toaster oven, you've probably had an Instant Pot at some point. Given that it's a brand that's known for making some of the best air fryers and the best pressure cookers, it makes sense to stick to the brand when looking to buy new small kitchen appliances. That's why we've gone out to find our favorite Instant Pot appliances, whether it's a pressure cooker or a Dutch oven, and collected them all below to help save you some extra legwork.
Instant Pot RIO 7-in-1 Electric Multi-Cooker -- $88, was $100

Not all Instant Pot devices need to cost a lot of money, and this budget-friendly Instant Pot Rio will give you a lot of functionality for less than $100. While it primarily functions as a pressure cooker, you can also use it for cooking rice, making yogurt, warming food, and even sauté. The controls are also pretty simple, so you don't have to worry about pressing through complex menus, and the fact that the lid and internal pan are dishwasher safe means it's really easy to wash as well, which is a huge plus.

Read more