Qtrax Ad-Based P2P Music Service Hits Snag

By Geoff Duncan January 28, 2008

Qtrax Ad-Based P2P Music Service Hits Snag

Revamped online music service Qtrax turned on its lights at midnight last night, and already they’ve hit a snag: Warner Music Group, Universal, and EMI say it never agreed to be on board.

Qtrax is supposed to combine the breadht of music available via peer-to-peer services like Gnutella and BitTorrent with an ad-supported mechanism which actually compensates artists and labels for users downloading their music. Unlike traditional online music services like iTunes, Qtrax claims to provide access to more than 25 million tracks—and it can make that claim only because it operates essentially has a front end to the Gnutella file sharing network. The vast majority of those tracks have not been licensed for online sale, but Qtrax says it will keep track of everything and work out the details with copyright holders so that everyone gets appropriately compensated for downloads.

Using Qtrax, users can download tracks for free so long as they’re willing to tolerate advertisements. They also have to be willing to tolerate Windows DRM: while the tracks may traverse the Gnutella file-sharing network in unprotected form, Qtrax is wrapping Windows DRM around them and explicitly tracking what its users do with the music, including how many times they listen to a song. Qtrax also says it plans to release a Macintosh client in March, and offer support for the iPod—that probably means the company is working on reverse-engineering Apple FairPlay DRM, which could lead to a technology race with Apple, not to mention legal action.

Qtrax has positioned itself as a label-approved service, but now that QTrax has launched, it seems the major labels aren’t all lined up: Warner Music Group has issued a statement saying the company “has not authorized the use of our content on Qtrax’s recently announced service,” and EMI and Universal have confirmed they have not signed licensing deals with Qtrax. Qtrax says agreements will be reached “shortly.”

Qtrax got its start back in the heady days following Napster’s shutdown over copyright infringement allegations, starting as a peer-to-peer client that offers users access to music files stored on other users’ computers. The service shut down for several months in 2002 to dodge legal action.

Topics

Apple

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Smart Home

How to reset the Nanoleaf Skylight

The Nanoleaf Skylight lighting up a room various shades of purple.

The Nanoleaf Skylight is a unique piece of hardware. Unlike most Nanoleaf products that are quick to install or easy to move and replace, the Skylight is designed as a permanent fixture in your home. Instead of simply plugging it into an electrical outlet, you'll need to hardwire it onto your ceiling – and once it's in place, you'll want it to stay there for years.

However, like all electronics, it's possible for your Nanoleaf Skylight to start acting up. And since there's no easy way to get the entire unit down from your ceiling, you might be wondering how you can quickly solve the problem. Thankfully, Nanoleaf designed a simple way for you to reset the Nanoleaf Skylight without the need to disassemble the entire setup.

Smart Home

Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra vs. Narwal Freo X Ultra: Which is the best premium robot vacuum?

Narwal Freo X Ultra with dock in home

Few robot vacuums and mops are as well-rounded as the Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra and Narwal Freo X Ultra. The two premium robots will vacuum and mop entirely on their own, before returning to their docks to automatically clean their mopheads and empty their dustbins. That sort of functionality doesn't come cheap, with both products carrying hefty price tags that'll put a big dent in your budget.

Because they're so expensive, you'll want to pay close attention to the differences between these two robot vacuums. Both are great additions to any household, but one might be a better fit for your needs than the other.

Smart Home

Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra vs. Roborock S8 Max Ultra: Which is the better robot vacuum?

The Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra placed in its dock.

The Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra and Roborock S8 Max Ultra are two of the newest additions to the Roborock family. Along with having almost identical names, these robot vacuums share much of the same spec sheet -- including the ability to mop and vacuum in a single cycle before automatically emptying their dustbin and cleaning their mops. They're impressive gadgets by all accounts, but since they're wildly expensive, you'll want to carefully compare the Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra and Roborock S8 Max Ultra before adding one to your home.

If you need help, here's a comprehensive look at these two premium robot vacuums, including a comparison of their vacuuming and mops skills, a look at their docking station perks, and a final determination of which is likely best for your needs. Keep in mind that you really can't go wrong with either product -- after all, they're two of the most expensive robots in the category -- but one might be a slightly better fit for your household than the other.
Pricing and availability