Skip to main content

Tech fails: 5 smart home products that failed miserably

smart home tech failures spinning ice cream cone
Image used with permission by copyright holder
According to an old English proverb, “necessity is the mother of invention.” While this may hold true for some products, it’s certainly not always the case. Did anyone really need a pet rock? What about a slap bracelet, or a blanket with sleeves?

Inventors can create new products that work just a little bit better than an existing one on the market, while others are simply cool gadgets we’d like to have. Some inventions make our lives simpler and save us a few steps in the kitchen, while others prevent us from having to get off the couch.

Recommended Videos

Their innovation and contribution to the smart home products we have today.

As time goes by, more and more people are trying their hand at invention and entrepreneurship. From 1965 to 1995, the number of annual patent applications more than doubled. Then, from 1995 to 2015, the number of applications almost tripled.

With all of the portable communication devices, smart home products, and peripheral devices, a whole new window of opportunity exists for entrepreneurs, some of whom are successful. The rest … not so much.

We’ve compiled a list of early smart home tech that didn’t make the cut. Some of these products had conceptual flaws, some were ahead of their time, and others didn’t serve a meaningful purpose. While these smart home technologies seem cool, for one reason or another, they still failed.

RJ Reynolds Premier Cigarettes (1988)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Premier cigarettes heated tobacco rather than burning it. The “smokeless” cigarettes purported to reduce the harmful effects of smoking, providing a “healthier” alternative at a time when people were beginning to seriously criticize the tobacco industry for the health risks associated with cigarettes.

When RJ Reynolds tested its Premier cigarettes in a small market, customers reported that they tasted horrible. And the public did not see them as a “healthier” alternative. Sound familiar?

iSmell Digiscents (2001)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Aside from the fact that this product sounds like it’s designed to cover up body odor, this little gadget failed for other reasons. Though it produced hundreds of scents that allowed users smell what he or she was viewing online, the market wasn’t interested in an owning an expensive “scent database.”

NCR Microwave Bank (1998)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This microwave connected to the internet, and appeared to have a lot of potential. It was even named Technology Innovation of the Year at the Annual Technology for Retail Banking Conference. Perhaps the smart microwave was simply ahead of its time.

Motorized Ice Cream Cone (1999)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Tired of turning your hand to avoid getting melted ice cream on yourself? This little gadget spins and vibrates, so you don’t have to do any extra work while eating your ice cream cone. While this product hasn’t exactly caught on, you can actually still buy it on Amazon today.

CueCat Barcode Scanner (2000)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This device allowed you to scan a barcode from a catalog or an article. Then, if you connected the device to your computer, you could get information about the product without having to enter a URL in the address bar. While it does have purpose and a unique feline design, it was too much work for such a small payoff.

Each of these inventions helped to pave the way for other successful products. Premier cigarettes didn’t work out, but society is now beginning to see vaping as a viable smoking cessation method. Sure, no one wanted to buy a product called “iSmell,” but more and more VR products have flooded the market in the time since. The world may not have been ready for NCR’s Microwave Bank, but we now have a variety of Wi-Fi-connected appliances to choose from.

So yes, these products did fail. But we should give them some credit for their innovation and contribution to the smart home products we have today.

Erika Rawes
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Erika became a professional writer in 2010, and her work is published all over the web on sites ranging from USA Today to…
Ring Protect rebrands to Ring Home and adds 24/7 recording
The Ring Video Doorbell Pro 2 installed near a door.

Ring owners seeking to unlock everything their devices have to offer are likely familiar with Ring Protect Plans. By paying a monthly fee, you can access features such as 180-day video history, snapshot capture, and smart alerts. Today, Ring has officially rebranded Ring Protect to Ring Home -- and it’s gained some cool functionality while still retaining the same pricing structure.

Previously offered as Ring Protect Basic, Protect Plus, or Protect Pro, you’ll soon be greeted with Ring Home Basic ($5 per month), Home Standard ($10 per month), and Home Premium ($20 per month). All that’s changed here is the name, as your monthly payments will remain identical to the old Protect Plans. However, you can now add individual services to the Home Standard and Home Premium Plans -- so if you want to tack on a Virtual Security Guard or Alarm Professional Monitoring, you can do so for an extra fee.

Read more
The next Apple HomeKit device could blend HomePod, iPad, and AI
Apple HomePod 2023

Apple HomeKit has always lagged behind Alexa and Google Assistant, notably lacking a smart display similar to that of the Echo Show 15 or the Nest Hub. Rumors suggest that the company's next gadget might rectify that. MacRumors reported code found in Apple's backend that referenced something called HomeAccessory17,1. That might not seem like much to go on until you realize that HomePod is similarly named AudioAccessory.

There are still too few details to make any definitive conclusions, but we can venture an educated guess that the upcoming device might be powered by the A18 chip and feature AI-focused features. Apple already has plans to integrate OpenAI and Siri. Adding AI-powered intelligence into a smart home system would potentially give it never-before-seen functionality — perhaps even more than what Alexa can currently offer, although Google Assistant's use of Gemini could level the playing field.

Read more
Home Depot expands Hubspace with a smart door, smart lock, and other cool gadgets
The new Hubspace smart door and smart lock.

Home Depot held its Hubspace Fall Preview event today, showcasing a variety of smart home products arriving later this year. One of the coolest new additions to the catalog is the Smart Glass Door by Feather River Doors, as it lets you toggle between clear or opaque glass via voice commands and syncs with most smart home platforms. Home Depot also revealed a smart lock, smart freezer, string lights, and home alarm system -- all of which are fully supported by the simple-to-use Hubspace app.

The Smart Glass Door is undoubtedly the most unique item in the upcoming collection. Pricing starts at $798 with a launch date of September 30, and it’s looking to bring some seriously cool features to your home. The big allure is the central glass pane, which can quickly change between clear and opaque styles using voice commands or a physical button. That means you can activate clear mode when you want a bit of sunshine, then swap to opaque mode for privacy. Beyond Hubspace, it integrates with Alexa and Google Assistant.

Read more