Skip to main content

FBI can still hack other iPhone 5C models on iOS 9, paid under $1M for technique

FBI Director
FBI Director James Comey Image used with permission by copyright holder
Last week, FBI Director James Comey let slip that the bureau paid more than the amount of money he’ll make in the remainder of his term for the technique that cracked the San Bernardino shooter’s iPhone. If that were true, it seems that Comey may have taken a pay cut.

Reuters calculated the amount to be more than $1.3 million based on his annual salary as of January 2015, which was $183,300. But Reuters is now reporting, according to various, unnamed sources, that the government paid less than $1 million. The original figure would have been the largest sum paid for a hacking technique, but it doesn’t seem to be the case anymore.

Recommended Videos

Perhaps more importantly, the FBI will indeed be able to use the technique to unlock other iPhone 5C models on iOS 9. It’s the same version and phone left behind by Syed Farook, one of the two shooters who killed 14 people in San Bernardino, California, last December.

Comey previously said the technique would only work on a “narrow slice of phones” — Apple’s newer devices have improved encryption technology.

The bureau paid professional “gray hat” hackers to unlock the iPhone 5C. But the phone sparked a monthlong legal battle between Apple and the FBI, as Apple refused to create a special tool to provide access into the phone.

Apple feared that, in the wrong hands, the tool could be used against all of its customers, threatening their privacy and security. The Cupertino company’s sentiments were echoed by many other tech companies, privacy advocates, and human rights groups, as well as legal, tech, cryptology, and cybersecurity experts. The FBI dropped the case after the team of anonymous hackers successfully cracked the phone.

When Comey was asked how much the government paid, his response was: “More than I will make in the remainder of this job, which is seven years and four months for sure. But it was, in my view, worth it.”

But while the FBI still may have shelled out a lot of money to own the technique, it doesn’t know the entire details of how it works. It’s why the bureau isn’t disclosing the technique to Apple or the White House.

The White House has an internal review group, the Vulnerabilities Equities Process, which decides whether or not to inform companies of security vulnerabilities found by government agencies. The FBI claims since it didn’t discover the vulnerability, and the fact that its agents don’t fully understand how it works, the bureau won’t have anything to share if a review is launched.

Reuters says not even Comey knows the identity of the team of hackers that broke into the iPhone.

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
The best language-learning apps for 2024
best language learning apps.

Do you need help to learn a new language? You'll wish you'd known about these apps sooner. Learning a foreign tongue can be a real headache. But these top language-learning apps make it easy and fun with bite-sized lessons, quizzes, speech recognition, and more.

From gamified vocabulary builders like Memrise to apps that use TV shows to teach you a new language, there's something for every learning style and goal. Whether you want to master Spanish verb conjugations, read French novels easily, or learn some travel phrases, these apps have you covered. They are available for Android-based devices like the Pixel 9 Pro XL and Apple devices like the iPhone 16.
Duolingo

Read more
iOS 18.2 just took another step toward its official release
iOS 18 logo on the iPhone 16 Pro

Yet another iOS update is ready, and this one is important. The iOS 18.2 beta 2 update is live, and it's a big deal for a couple of reasons. It's available to more people than the previous beta, and it indicates another step toward iOS 18.2's public launch.

The first version of this beta was only available to people whose phones supported Apple Intelligence, but this latest version works with any phone that can update to iOS 18. Addditionally, iOS 18.2 beta 2 is only available to developer beta testers. There isn't a public beta at the moment, and we have no word on when one might release. Still, it's good to see that more people are included this time around.

Read more
A new update fixes the Snapdragon 8 Elite’s overheating issues — or does it?
The back of the Realme GT 7 Pro.

Since we performance tested the new Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Elite processor in the GT 7 Pro smartphone, Realme has insisted it has a fix coming for what it described as a “software compatibility” problem, which was causing the phone to overheat before it could complete a 20-minute gaming benchmark test.

Today, a software update containing the fix was delivered to our review model, with the promise it would solve the issue. Sure enough, after running the Solar Bay Stress Test — a 20-minute program that emulates gameplay with ray-traced graphics — in the 3DMark benchmark app, the Realme GT 7 Pro did indeed successfully complete it, giving us the performance figures we were missing during our initial comparison with the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 in the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra.
Still running hot
Realme GT 7 Pro results from the 3DMark Solar Bay Stress Test Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Read more