Skip to main content

Federal appeals court charges Apple $450M fine for fixing ebook prices

apple ebookpricing supreme court case ibooks
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Apple’s ebook price-fixing saga has finally come to a quiet close, it seems. A federal appeals court ruled 2-1 against the company this morning, affirming the finding of U.S. District Judge Denis Cote that the Cupertino-based company illegally colluded with publishers to prop up the prices of digital books.

“Apple orchestrated a conspiracy among the publishers to raise ebook prices.”

Recommended Videos

“We conclude that the district court correctly decided that Apple orchestrated a conspiracy among the publishers to raise ebook prices,” wrote Second Circuit Judge Debra Ann Livingston in today’s decision.

It’s the outcome of charges brought by the Justice Department three years ago, which alleged that Apple organized an ebook pricing scheme, a violation of federal antitrust law. The company fought the litigation intensely, denying wrongdoing and “refusing to settle unlike the publishers with whom it allegedly colluded,” the Wall Street Journal reports.

The Justice Department’s lawsuit, which 33 states went on to join, was filed in 2012 after evidence arose that Apple willfully influenced the ebook market. The company led the charge to supplant the wholesale model for ebooks, which before the introduction of its iBooks store was the industry standard, with an agency model that granted publishers the right to dictate prices. Under the terms of a collective agreement with Hachette, Simon & Schuster, HarperCollins, Penguin, and Macmillan, Apple received a larger cut of sales in return.

The arrangement was mutually beneficial. Apple was able to quickly fill its newly-launched ebooks storefront, and publishers were given leverage against Amazon, which came to command between 80 and 90 percent of all ebooks sales in 2010 through aggressive pricing. Under the agency model, ebook prices quickly rose.

Despite today’s decision, Apple isn’t entirely without recourse — it could petition the Supreme Court or ask the Second Circuit to rehear the case. But the Wall Street Journal reports that the company’s expected to pay $450 million — most of it to customers of its iBooks store — as part of an agreement made with the Justice Department and plaintiffs in November.

“Apple did not conspire to fix ebook pricing and this ruling does nothing to change the facts. We are disappointed the Court does not recognize the innovation and choice the iBooks Store brought for consumers,” Apple said in a statement. “While we want to put this behind us, the case is about principles and values. We know we did nothing wrong in 2010 and are assessing next steps.”

Those sound like fighting words, but should Apple finally decide to pony up, it wouldn’t hurt the company’s bottom line too severely. As the Wall Street Journal notes, the proposed settlement amounts to less than 3 percent of Apple’s 2014 fourth quarter revenue.

Kyle Wiggers
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kyle Wiggers is a writer, Web designer, and podcaster with an acute interest in all things tech. When not reviewing gadgets…
Own the Galaxy Watch 6 for less than $200, but act fast!
Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 on its charger.

Welcome to the world of wearables. From smartwatch deals to fitness deals, we always have our eyes peeled for the best discounts on top-rated tech from brands like Apple, Google, and Samsung. Speaking of the Big S, we came across this fantastic offer while vetting through Best Buy deals:

Right now, when you purchase the 44mm Graphite version of the Samsung Galaxy Watch 6, you’ll only pay $190. At full price, this model sells for $330. We tested the Galaxy Watch 6 well over a year ago, and our reviewer had this to say: “The Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 is the new go-to recommendation if you want an Android smartwatch. It's reliable, powerful, and still a great value.”

Read more
Yes, Reddit is down. Here’s everything you need to know
The Reddit app icon on an iOS Home screen.

Bad news, fellow Redditors. If you're trying to browse your favorite subreddit right now, you're probably unable to. Why? Because Reddit appears to be down due to technical difficulties.

What's going on with the outage? Do we know when it'll be back up? Here's a recap of everything we know.
Why is Reddit down?
On the Reddit status website, the company indicates an "unresolved incident" taking place on November 20. The company confirms "degraded performance for reddit.com," which appears to be accurate.

Read more
I traveled 8,000 miles to get an Android phone unlike any I’ve used before
Someone holding the Lava Agni 3 smartphone.

The U.S. smartphone market is a well-known entity in 2024. Apple dominates the flagship space with the iPhone, Samsung's Galaxy S handsets are a reliable force every year, and Google's Pixel phones continue improving. But what about budget phones? There are some decent choices from Google, Motorola, and OnePlus, but your options are limited.

It's a trusty, if somewhat unexciting, swath of smartphones, especially when you get a glimpse at what's happening in other parts of the world. On a recent trip to India with MediaTek to see the company's presence in the Indian tech market firsthand, I was given the Lava Agni 3 — a new smartphone release from the India-based company Lava.

Read more