Skip to main content

Apple may have provided flawed evidence to European judge in Samsung Tab 10.1 case

iPad Samsung Tab 10.1 side by side altered SamsungApple’s case against Samsung is based on the fact that it believes the Samsung Tab 10.1 looks too much like its iPad. In the evidence provided by Apple to a European judge, the company included a side-by-side picture of the iPad and Tab 10.1 that might not be as accurate as possible. The picture in question has both products side by side, and they look strikingly similar in size and shape, which is why the Samsung tablet is currently banned from being sold in most European countries.

It appears that the picture of the Tab 10.1 has been altered in that picture, and now looks more square shaped than it actually is. The Apple iPad has a 4:3 aspect ratio and is slightly more square shaped than the Tab 10.1, which has a widescreen 16:10 aspect ratio, but in the picture they look nearly identical. It looks as though the bottom edge of the Tab 10.1 is missing, which is why the aspect ratios of the two devices look so similar.  In the altered picture included in the lawsuit, the Tab 10.1 aspect ratio is closer to the iPads than it is to its original ratio.

Recommended Videos

We have yet to hear a response from Apple or its lawyers about the issue, but are very interested in what they have to say. We also do not yet know if the same picture was used in Apple’s case blocking the Tab 10.1 in Australia.

It is too soon to know if the picture was altered on purpose or not, but either way it seems as though this situation is far from over. In a case that hinges on how similar two products look, this might be a pretty damaging hole in Apple’s case.

Mike Dunn
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Mike graduated from University of Arizona with a degree in poetry, and made his big break by writing love sonnets to the…
Apple just admitted defeat to Android phones
A Google Pixel 8 Pro in Porcelain (left) with an iPhone 15 Pro in Blue Titanium held in hand.

For years, Apple’s smartphones have held a decisive upper hand over Android devices in one crucial aspect: the longevity of the software support cycle. In a nutshell, as long as your phone keeps getting updates, it will run just about fine.

Brand assurances play a crucial role in buyer behavior, as long-term update support means your phone will not only get new tricks but also security flaws patched. Notably, Apple is not into the habit of quoting how many years it will offer software support for each device, but it has held the crown for a while.

Read more
How to watch Apple’s big iPad event on May 7
iPad Air 5 back in hand.

After what seems like forever, Apple is finally holding an iPad-focused press event. The "Let Loose" event is scheduled for Tuesday, May 7.

The online-only event is expected to reveal new iPad Pro and iPad Air models, as well as tablet accessories, including a new Apple Pencil. Here's more about the event and how to watch it.
How to watch Apple's May 7 event
Apple Event - May 7

Read more
The 4 biggest announcements we expect from Apple’s May 7 event
Apple May 7th event promo on Apple website, on iPad.

It's been a long time since Apple introduced new iPads. In fact, you'd have to go back to October 2022 to find the last time the company released a new tablet. That's about to change, however. On Tuesday, May 7, at its "Let Loose" event, Apple is expected to announce at least four new tablets, as well as iPad accessories.

Here's a look at what we expect — and what we don't — at this May event.
2024 iPad Pro

Read more