Skip to main content

Apple, Samsung top J.D. Power mobile phone satisfaction

J.D. Power 2011 Mobile Satisfaction Smartphones
Image used with permission by copyright holder

J.D Power and Associates has released its 2011 studies assessing consumers’ overall satisfaction with both smartphones and traditional mobile handsets—and the overall rankings contain few surprises, with Apple showing a strong lead in the smartphone category (with HTC the only other company to beat the industry average), while Samsung just barely edged out LG and Sanyo to claim top honors in the feature phone category. Overall, consumers showed much higher levels of satisfaction with smartphones than with traditional mobile handsets.

However, it’s almost more interesting to note what companies ended up at the bottom of the heap: amongst smartphones, Nokia devices ranked even lower in satisfaction amongst U.S. consumers than Palm/webOS devices, and in feature phones only Kyocera ranked lower than Nokia. And Google’s latest big acquisition—Motorola Mobility—didn’t even beat the industry average in either category.

Recommended Videos

“It’s not unexpected that satisfaction is higher for devices that have new technological advances or features,” said J.D. Power and Associations senior director of wireless services Kirk Parsons, in a statement. “Having the right combination of physical dimensions and operating functions and features for both smartphones and traditionally equipped devices is key to creating an exceptional ownership experience with each type of wireless device.”

J.D. Power 2011 Mobile Satisfaction traditional handsets
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The study found several factors directly impacted customer satisfaction with smartphones: J.D. Power found that consumers are more satisfied with phones that are lighter, thinner, and offer touchscreen control rather than QWERTY keypads or a mix of touchscreen and QWERTY keypads. Consumers also prefer fast processing speed, high-quality displays, and the resolution of a phone’s camera is also a contributing factor. In general, the more megapixels a phone’s camera offers, the higher a customers’ satisfaction will be, although the cutoff is about 5 megapixels: customers weren’t significantly more satisfied with 8 megapixels or more than they were with 5 megapixels.

J.D. Power also found U.S. consumers are very satisfied with 4G-enabled devices, with the average satisfaction of 4G users significantly higher than that of 3G users; the study also found 4G users are more active users of their devices, engaging in more calling, texting, and Internet use.

The 2011 results mark the sixth consecutive time Apple ranked highest amongst smartphone manufacturers for customer satisfaction.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
The Galaxy S25 Ultra’s camera crushed its old rival in our test
The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the Galaxy S25 Ultra's cameras.

Is the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra worth an upgrade if you own the last Ultra phone? Equally, if the Galaxy S25 Ultra is on your buy list, understanding how Samsung has improved the camera this time around will be an important point to understand before splashing out on it. To help answer these questions, we put Samsung’s latest Ultra phone against its predecessor, the Galaxy S24 Ultra, in a serious camera battle.
Camera specs
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (left) and the Galaxy S25 Ultra Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

The first thing to understand is not much has changed on the hardware front. Both have a 200-megapixel main camera with an f/1.7 aperture, phase-detection autofocus (PDAF) and optical image stabilization (OIS). It’s joined by a pair of telephoto cameras on both, one 10MP telephoto with OIS for a 3x optical zoom, and another 50MP telephoto with OIS for a 5x optical zoom.

Read more
The Garmin Lily 2 Active has a $50 discount, but don’t wait!
Garmin Lily 2 smartwatch being worn on wrist.

Smartwatches have become quite a popular fitness tool over the last several years, but these gadgets can do far more than help you count calories. Some of the best models can even receive notifications from your phone, allowing you to stay connected when you’re out for a casual stroll. And when it comes to smartwatch deals, one brand we’re always glad to see promos from is Garmin.

As a matter of fact, we came across a great Garmin offer earlier today: For a limited time, when you purchase the Garmin Lily 2 Active through Amazon, Crutchfield, or Best Buy, you’ll only pay $250. The full MSRP on this model is $300.

Read more
Samsung could reinvent the S Pen for its next foldable phone
Rear view of Samsung Galaxy Z Fold Special Edition.

Samsung is reportedly making a major stylus input change for its next book-style foldable device as it moves forward in pursuit of slimmer phones. According to a report from ET News, the Galaxy Z Fold 7 will switch the stylus input to a format similar to that of the Apple Pencil.

Citing industry sources, the Korean outlet mentions that Samsung has decided to remove the digitizer element from the upcoming phone’s display assembly. The digitizer is a pressure-sensitive layer that converts the physical input from a stylus and converts those strokes into digital information.

Read more