BlackBerry sues Nokia, alleging networking patent infringement

By Julian Chokkattu Published February 16, 2017

blackberry vs nokia feat — Image used with permission by copyright holder

Two former smartphone kings, Nokia and BlackBerry, have become embroiled in a lawsuit involving patents relating to networking gear.

BlackBerry filed a lawsuit in a federal court in Delaware, according to Bloomberg, claiming Nokia is infringing on 11 patents with several mobile networking products, such as Flexi Multiradio base stations, Liquid Radio software, and radio network controllers.

Recommended Videos

The Canadian-based company said Nokia provides these devices and services to carriers such as T-Mobile and AT&T for their LTE networks, and BlackBerry alleges that “Nokia has persisted in encouraging the use” of these devices without a license.

Please enable Javascript to view this content

BlackBerry is not looking to block the use of the patents, though, and the company is instead seeking monetary damages, though it’s not clear exactly how much BlackBerry is hoping to get. BlackBerry is also likely looking to get Nokia to start licensing the patents.

Bloomberg reports that the bulk of the patents came from former telecoms giant Nortel Networks Corp., and the company bought them alongside a consortium after Nortel went bankrupt. The patents were reportedly split between the consortium, which included members such as Apple and Microsoft. Nokia tried to buy Nortel in 2009.

BlackBerry’s smartphone market share recently hit zero, according to research firm Gartner’s estimates. Both BlackBerry and Nokia are now licensing their smartphone business to other manufacturers that will retain their respective brand names.

Nokia has turned to virtual reality and its telecommunications prowess, while its acquisition of Withings keeps it active in the health and wearable category. BlackBerry, on the other hand, is improving its security software on its licensed handsets, while also pivoting towards self-driving technology.

Topics

Julian Chokkattu

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…

Mobile

TCL won’t make BlackBerry phones anymore, sending the brand back into limbo

BlackBerry Key2 LE review

TCL Communication has announced it will no longer be making BlackBerry smartphones, after taking over the dormant brand at the end of 2016, and bringing it back to life with a series of ever-improving devices. In a statement tweeted out by the official BlackBerry Mobile account, TCL Communication does not have the rights to design, manufacture, or sell BlackBerry phones any longer.

This means the BlackBerry Key 2 LE will be the last BlackBerry-branded phone produced by TCL Communication to be released, and it follows the BlackBerry Key 2, and the BlackBerry KeyOne. TCL Communication’s BlackBerry phones took the features fans of the brand loved — the physical keyboard, long battery life, and extra levels of security — and put them inside modern hardware with Google Android software. While not for everyone, they were successful with those either familiar with the brand, or those looking for something a little different.
What does this mean for BlackBerry?
The future of BlackBerry phones is once again unknown. While TCL Communication will not make another BlackBerry phone, it does not necessarily mean we will never see another BlackBerry phone. It’s possible the global license could be snapped up by another company eager to capitalize on the brand’s highly recognizable name. HMD Global, for example, has seen considerable success with the Nokia name since acquiring the license, while British phone maker Bullitt owns the license to make phones from brands including Cat, JCB, and Land Rover.

Mobile

Samsung has a smartphone design problem

Three Galaxy S24 Plus models laying on a table, including the white, gray, and yellow ones.

The year was 2015. Back when the obsession was making the thinnest phones out there. Chinese smartphone brands made their presence felt in the race, out-slimming the big boys. Vivo’s crown jewel was merely 4.75mm across.

Even Samsung partook and launched a phone that beat Apple at the cross-section game. A decade later, the wheels of smartphone design are turning back to slim phones.

Mobile

I have the new Mocha Mousse color for the Motorola Razr Plus, and it’s stunning

The Mocha Mousse Motorola Razr Plus in someone's pocket.

The Motorola Razr Plus 2024 stands tall as one of the year's best folding phones. It's highly performant and has good cameras, solid software, and a striking design. That last point was one of my favorite aspects of the phone when I reviewed it this summer, and just in time for the new year, Motorola found a way to ensure the Razr Plus continues to be a design leader heading into 2025.

Earlier this month, Motorola announced its new Mocha Mousse color for the Razr Plus. I thought the renders looked good, but as with any smartphone color, it's difficult to get the full experience until it's in your hands.