Skip to main content

FCC chairman’s Net neutrality revisions may not be enough to silence dissent

fcc chairmans net neutrality revisions may enough silence dissent tom wheeler
Image used with permission by copyright holder

FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler has reportedly backed down from his agency’s broadband Internet regulation proposals, introducing a new draft that promises stronger scrutiny to keep ISPs from discriminating against companies that can’t afford to pay for Internet “fast lanes.”  

According to the Wall Street Journal, Wheeler assured the public that he would not allow broadband companies to segregate Internet traffic into slow and fast lanes. While the development may be a positive sign for Net neutrality advocates, it isn’t a complete turnaround, and may fall short of satisfying critics.

Recommended Videos

 The new draft still allows broadband companies to charge more for faster delivery of content. The only difference is the language. According to an unnamed official, the FCC will scrutinize deals between broadband and content providers to make sure that nonpaying companies don’t get unfair treatment.  

While the agency’s promises probably wouldn’t be enough to quell dissent, there are aspects to the new draft that may be taken as a positive sign by Net neutrality advocates. The unnamed official said that the new proposals would seek comments on whether to ban “paid prioritization.” The draft will also ask for comments on whether to consider broadband Internet providers as a public utility, which would allow the FCC to regulate the industry. 

In a blog post on the Stanford Law School Center for Internet and Society website, experts said that while giving the public a chance to comment on paid prioritization is a step in the right direction, the draft is just a rehash of the same bad rules. 

“Though we haven’t yet seen the FCC’s proposal, it seems that the Chairman is considering requiring ISPs to offer a baseline level of service to applications, content, and services that don’t pay up. So instead of an Internet with a slow lane and a fast lane, the new proposal might result in an Internet that offers a “not-so-fast, but not totally crappy lane” to applications that don’t pay and a “faster lane” to those that do,” the blog post read. “Internet companies that pay so that their traffic is faster or is not counted against the bandwidth cap have a competitive advantage. This is one of the key policy problems with access fees. Simply improving the quality of the baseline service does not remove that problem, because the quality differential between paying and non-paying applications remains.”

The new proposed rules come as Wheeler faces a revolt within his own agency. Last week, FCC commissioners Ajit Pai and Jessica Rosenworcel called for a delay on the March 15 vote on the proposal. In the Wall Street Journal article, an unnamed FCC official was quoted as saying: “There is a wide feeling on the eighth floor that this is a debacle and I think people would like to see a change of course … We may not agree on the course, but we agree the road we’re on is to disaster.” 

While your comments won’t have as much weight as an FCC commissioner, it still counts. So if you want to add your comments on this issue, you can shoot an email to the FCC’s new inbox at openinternet@fcc.gov.

Christian Brazil Bautista
Christian Brazil Bautista is an experienced journalist who has been writing about technology and music for the past decade…
Like the other ESR Gear deals? Here are some more: Case, screen protector, more
ESR Gear deals -- Aura wallet stand (HaloLock)

As far as mobile phone accessories go, ESR Gear has some incredible deals live for the holidays with great prices on a multi-functional stand, car charger and mount, and MagSafe power bank. But if you're not interested in any of those, don't worry, you won't be left out in the cold. There are more ESR Gear deals to be had, and we're just as excited about these. Like the other deals, some of these mobile accessories are already discounted but you can save an extra 10% on top with an exclusive coupon code. Just be warned, all coupon codes expire December 25th, so don't waste too much time window shopping if you're interested.

 
ESR Armorite screen protector -- $14 $17 20% off
Compatible with iPhone 15, and iPhone 16 models, this hardened screen protector offers the ultimate protection for your device's most valuable asset. It's easy to install, bubble and dust-free and comes with everything you need to attach the protector, including a working tray. It's made of 9H+ glass with 110 pounds of SGS-certified protection and resistance. Each pack comes with three protectors and there is a privacy glass option -- though it's not on sale currently.

Read more
How to turn off Siri on your iPhone, iPad, or Apple Watch
How to turn off Siri

While it has its detractors, Siri is still a popular virtual assistant for folks with an iPhone, iPad, or Apple Watch — and that's not simply because it's built into those devices. Siri may not be able to answer all of your queries, but it still has many useful features. It can play your favorite tunes, set reminders, send quick messages, and control devices around your home.

Still, not everyone needs a virtual assistant at their beck and call, so if you'd prefer to keep Siri out of the way, Apple has provided a way to switch it off on one or all of your Apple devices.

Read more
Best Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra deals: Get Samsung’s flagship for $200
The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and S Pen stylus on its screen.

The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is the largest of Samsung’s latest phones, and to many it’s considered one of the best phones on the market. It’s a good phone to consider if you aren’t finding what you’re looking for among the best Samsung Galaxy S24 deals or best Samsung Galaxy S23 deals, as its larger size delivers more screen real estate but also sometimes more savings. There are several ways to save on a Galaxy S24 Ultra scattered across carriers and retailers, so we’ve rounded up all of the best Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra deals below. Some of them could are up there with the best phone deals, and they’re nice alternatives if the current Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra deals feel a little dated, and they price the phone nicely among all of the iPhone deals and Google Pixel 8 deals taking place right now.
Today's best Galaxy S24 Ultra deals
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra deals change frequently but below, we’ve picked out some of the best available today. These include being able to buy directly from Samsung, along with buying from other retailers and cell phone network providers. There’s something for every intention here.

: Get up to $800 of instant trade-in credit along with a choice of exclusive colors.
: Get up to $1,000 trade-in credit applied over 36 months.
: Get the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra for $5 per month for 36 months with a new Unlimited Ultimate plan.
: Get the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra for up to $1,100 off.
: Save $100 on the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra when you trade-in your current phone.

Read more