Google gets early win in Oracle patent battle

By Geoff Duncan June 24, 2011

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Oracle’s patent infringement suit against Google over the Java implementation in Android may be facing a significant setback: of the 21 patents Oracle claims Google is violating, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has rejected 17 claims on re-examination. As a result, the judge in the case has asked both Oracle and Google to reduce the number of claims they are making against each other in order to avoid wasting the court’s time on patents that will likely be ruled invalid or uninfringed.

The U.S. Patent and Trademark office ruling was first reported by Groklaw.

Recommended Videos

Oracle has not yet indicated how it intends to proceed in the case, but options include appealing the patent re-examination, reducing the number of claims it is making against Google. Earlier this month, Oracle began to describe the damages it aims to collect from Google in the case: one court filing estimates the damages at over $6 billion. Google has disputed the manner in which Oracle arrived at its figures.

Oracle filed suit against Google last year over alleged patent violation in the Java virtual machine used in Android. Google maintains it has done nothing wrong.

Overall, Oracle has made 168 infringement claims against Google to on seven patents. The USPTO’s process is ongoing.

Topics

Google

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Mobile

The Google Home app is getting a long-overdue feature

According to the sleuths over at Android Authority, the Google Home app is about to get a much-needed feature that I'm honestly shocked hasn't been added yet: a search bar.

If you've never used the Google Home app before, it's sort of the command center for all things smart home in the Google smart home ecosystem. If you only have a few smart home devices, it's easy enough to navigate — but if you have an extensive smart home setup, you could have upwards of 50 devices listed in the app. If you don't take time to organize and label them, it gets unwieldy fast.

Mobile

Have a Google Pixel 9 Pro? Do this to get a free year of Gemini Advanced

Google Gemini Advanced running on the Pixel 9 Pro XL.

There are lots of great Android phones out right now, and Google's new Google Pixel 9 series is among the best options. With excellent hardware, top-notch cameras, and surprisingly good battery life, there's a whole lot to like. However, they're also expensive, starting at $999 for the small Pixel 9 Pro and going up to $1799 for the Pixel 9 Pro Fold.

Mobile

Google Pixel 9 vs. OnePlus 12: the battle for the $800 crown

The Pixel 9 and OnePlus 12 held at angles.

As smartphones become more expensive and the best smartphones exceed $1,000, a class of phones aims to offer the best bang for your buck without breaking the bank. The top phones at this price point offer everything the bigger phones do, but with trade-offs that don’t affect the overall price and allow companies to reach a lower sale price.

The OnePlus 12 is the epitome of this, with few trade-offs and a price tag that belies belief. It offers everything from the Plus or regular Pro phones that other phone makers do, but with a few things that make it a true OnePlus smartphone. This includes a large battery, superfast charging, impressive performance, a triple camera, and a gorgeous display.