Skip to main content

Google pits design teams against each other to create next winning Pixel phone

Google Pixel 3 XL review
Julian Chokkatu/Digital Trends

Google is rumored to have at least three design teams working on its future smartphones, and it’s a competition between them all to produce the final design. This comes just days before Google is expected to reveal the new Pixel 3a and Pixel 3a XL devices, which leaks show to be midrange smartphones with designs that are similar to the flagship Pixel phones released at the end of 2018.

The similar designs may turn out to be a disappointment to some, as the Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are hardly regarded as the most attractive devices of their time. Google’s apparent plan to have multiple design teams working in competition could be a reaction to the lukewarm reception to the controversial design decisions taken to create Pixel phones up until now. When we say controversial, we’re really talking about the notch, and the bezels.

Recommended Videos

It’s further evidence Google is working to alter its hardware divisions. In March, rumors spread it had asked members of its Create hardware team to find alternative roles, potentially for a temporary period of time, due to alterations to upcoming product plans. More pertinently, Google parent company Alphabet’s earnings for the first quarter of 2019 showed demand for the Pixel phones was low.

Exact figures were not stated, but Ruth Porat, Alphabet’s CFO, said there had been lower year-on-year sales of Pixel devices, and mostly laid the blame at the door of an overall drop in premium smartphone sales globally. However, the increase in focus on design across the industry marks the Pixel 3 devices out as being visually lacking, despite the technical prowess inside. The internal competition could help give it an edge, and avoid repeating the perceived design errors of the Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL.

Google does understand design, but has struggled with consistency. At the beginning of 2018, Google acquired HTC’s design team that had worked on Pixel devices already, with more than 2,000 engineers and designers joining the team. Its home hardware, including the Google Home Mini and Google Home Hub, are minimalist and attractive, with a focus on using tactile fabric to enhance them. This was part of an effort to create a consistent design language. In a recent interview, Google’s hardware design vice president Ivy Ross said, “It’s important that we keep the same language and signals up until such time where there’s a reason to evolve. I think we will evolve; we’ll keep our values but we’ll evolve. But really we’re just getting started.”

Three competing design divisions could be the start of that evolution, but it’s unclear whether we will see the results for the Pixel 4, or devices after that.

Andy Boxall
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
This Google app will make your Pixel look more like an iPhone
A person holding the Google Pixel 9.

As Google's Pixel line of phones has grown over the years, some fans have pointed out the increasing resemblance to the iPhone. The rounded edges, sleek design, and raised camera bump are all reminiscent of Apple's iconic device — especially with the newest Google Pixel 9.

Now, it looks like even the incoming call screen of the Google Phone app will be taking on an iPhone-like appearance. This is according to an APK breakdown by Android Authority.

Read more
2024 has been an unbelievable year for the Google Pixel
Wintergreen Pixel 9 with a Google "G" logo sign behind it.

This has been an insane year for mobile tech. Between Motorola's Razr flip phones, Samsung's latest foldables, IFA 2024, and the newest batch of iPhones, the last few months have been nonstop.

A little over a month ago, Google was part of that madness when it announced its Pixel 9 series of devices, and earlier this week, we finally published our Google Pixel 9 Pro Fold review. Google's latest foldable is a top-notch smartphone, and it wasn't the only piece of Google hardware we were impressed with this year. Almost every Google Pixel device we reviewed in 2024 was a runaway success, and it's a powerful testament to how much Google got right this year.
The Pixel 9 series is the real deal
The Google Pixel 9 Pro XL (left), Pixel 9 Pro, and Pixel 9 Ajay Kumar / Digital Trends

Read more
Future Pixel Watches could solve Google’s repairability problem
Someone wearing the Google Pixel Watch 3, showing the app drawer.

Google has a big problem: Its Pixel smartwatches are impossible to repair. Unless it's damage that's covered under Google's warranty, you're out of luck — and even then, you'll receive a replacement rather than a repaired unit. But that might be about to change.

At a technology-focused Climate Week NYC panel, Google executive Nicole Azores said the company is "thinking through" how to make the Pixel watch lineup repairable. Unfortunately, Azores didn't provide any more information or a timeline of any sort. As a rule, new tech products need two to three years for major developmental changes, so it's unclear whether next year's Pixel Watch 4 will be easier to fix. (Probably not.)

Read more