Skip to main content

‘Stolen’ iPhone 4 prototype criminal investigation nearly over

jason-chen-iphoneAfter nearly a year, the criminal investigation into Gizmodo.com‘s acquisition of a lost (and possibly stolen) iPhone 4 prototype will soon be complete, CNet reports. Authorities say they plan to release their report on the matter as soon as next month.

According to San Mateo, California, district attorney Stephen Wagstaffe, who spoke with CNet, “the investigation is ongoing,” but that investigators are conducing their final interviews of the case, and should present their findings to him shortly.

Recommended Videos

For those of you who don’t remember what has already become one of the most infamous stories in technology reporting history: The investigation centers around Gizmodo‘s purchase of an iPhone 4 prototype, lost at a Redwood City bar by 28-year-old Apple computer engineer Robert Gray Powell. The phone was found by 22-year-old college student Brian Hogan, who sold the phone to Gizmodo editor Jason Chen for $5,000.

Because Hogan sold the phone to Chen, the investigation has centered around whether this constitutes the exchange of stolen property — even though Hogan found the phone.

While no charges have yet been brought against Gawker Media, owner of Gizmodo, Chen or Hogan, it’s possible that all three could find themselves slapped with felony charges — Gawker Media and/or Chen for purchasing stolen property, Hogan for selling the phone rather than making a concerted effort to return it to its rightful owner (Apple).

Court documents show that Apple pressed San Mateo police to pursue the case a day after Gizmodo published photographs, video and details of the device. Soon after, police obtained a search warrant for Chen’s home, and confiscated various computers and other electronics as evidence for the investigation.

Because sale of the next-generation iPhone prototype involves a media organization, which has some robust protections under the Constitution’s First Amendment, the case is less than straightforward. It it not yet clear, however, whether Gawker Media, or Chen, are protected in this case.

Hogan may have less of a chance of avoiding charges, since California law seems to clearly state that anyone who “appropriates [found] property to his own use” is guilty of theft.

As for Powell, who lost the phone, CNet reports that his LinkedIn profile still shows that he works at Apple.

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
New iPhone SE 4 details just leaked. Here’s what we learned
The iPhone 14 Plus's main Home screen.

The iPhone SE will finally get a new look, though it might still appear identical to a two-generation-old mainline model. This nugget of information comes from Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman, who claims that the next “SE” trim could arrive early next year.

“The new model will resemble the iPhone 14, including the notch cutout at the top,” says the report. That means the upcoming iPhone could also be the last Apple smartphone with a physical home button with the integrated Touch ID sensor.

Read more
The Galaxy S25 Ultra may have another edge over the iPhone 16 Pro Max
The Desert Titanium iPhone 16 Pro.

The Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra is not likely to be revealed until early next year. However, that hasn't stopped a flood of rumors from circulating in recent months. The latest one comes from someone familiar, Ice Universe.

According to the leaker, the Galaxy S25 Ultra has bested Apple's recently released iPhone 16 Pro Max in terms of benchmarks. A result shared with Ice Universe showed that the phone achieved a single-core score of 3,011 and a multi-core result of 9,706. By contrast, its predecessor, the Galaxy S24 Ultra, has an average single-core score of 2,142 and an average multi-core score of 6,693. These are both significant jumps from one generation to the next.

Read more
4 things Apple got wrong with the iPhone 16 and 16 Pro
The pink iPhone 16 display.

Apple has lifted the curtain off the iPhone 16 and the Apple Watch Series 10, and it’s quite an exciting array of devices. Not only is this the first line of iPhones built from the ground up to support Apple Intelligence, but Apple also gave us some incredibly fun colors for the regular models.

Even so, Apple still fell short on some aspects of the iPhone 16 line. Let’s dive in.
The iPhone 16 still has a 60Hz display

Read more