Troll creators claim they came up with Harry Potter back in 1986

By Adam Poltrack Published April 25, 2023

Have you heard of Harry Potter Jr.? No, we’re not talking about some obscure piece of fan fiction, we’re talking about the boy who navigates a world full of witches, wizards, and magic to save his family from a nefarious troll who has hidden his essence in someone close to the young hero. You know, the kid played by Noah Hathaway (The NeverEnding Story) in the movie Troll, the one that came out back in 1986, 15 years before Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone.

Of course, you probably have no idea what we’re talking about. That’s because Troll was a forgettable B-movie that never developed even a fraction of the following that the Harry Potter franchise has. Still, there are certainly some striking similarities between the two stories.

So why is this in the news now?

Recommended Videos

Well, it seems that Filmmakers John Buechler and Peter Davy have signed Academy Award-winning actress Patricia Arquette to star in an animated remake of Troll called Troll: The Rise of Harry Potter Jr. Since that name is worth quite a bit of money to quite a few people, the filmmakers have hired Entertainment Attorney Tom Girardi, hoping to head off any legal issues in advance.

The two men do not plan to sue the current Harry Potter franchise for copyright infringement, though Buechler says that, if it weren’t for “family matters,” he might have brought a lawsuit back when J.K. Rowling’s books first came out.

Please enable Javascript to view this content

“We wanted to make sure that we weren’t going to be accused of plagiarism,” Davy told NBC Los Angeles. While Girardi added, “Even if someone who took it for a while makes it more valuable, that doesn’t take anything away from the fact that this is ours.”

A spokesperson for Warner Bros. and J.K. Rowling called Buechler and Davy’s claims “ridiculous” and the studio has released the following statement, “We will vigorously defend our intellectual property rights and challenge any unlawful attempt to capitalize on the extraordinary success of the Harry Potter franchise, as we told the filmmakers years ago.”

Rowling’s first Potter novel, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, came out in 1997 but she has said that the idea for the young wizard’s story came “fully formed” into her mind while on a train trip from Manchester to London back in 1990.

Could she have been influenced by Troll, which had been released just four years prior?

We’ll likely never know for sure. Chalk this up as another intriguing mystery from a universe full of witchcraft and wizardry.

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Adam is an A/V News Writer for Digital Trends, and is responsible for bringing you the latest advances in A/V…

Entertainment

All the new series heading to Max, including Penguin and Harry Potter

Colin Farrell in Max's Penguin spinoff.

HBO Max, as a brand, is no more. In its place, Warner Bros. Discovery is unveiling Max, the long-promised combination of HBO Max and Discovery+. And while the new Discovery shows don't exactly thrill us, the powers that be at WBD have dropped a lot of new information about Max original series that should help it hang on to the HBO crowd. And perhaps the biggest arrival is The Penguin, the upcoming spinoff from The Batman.

The Penguin | In-Production Teaser | Max

Entertainment

Rebooting Harry Potter as an HBO series is a bad idea

Neville, Hermione, Ron, and Harry inside a dark tunnel in HP and the Deathly Hallows Part 2.

Late on Monday afternoon, social media was set ablaze by the news that a new Harry Potter reboot was being discussed at Warner Bros. for HBO Max. The new series would adapt the seven books, one each season, offering another take on the Boy Who Lived's story. As if that wasn't bad enough, She-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named will be an active player on this reboot, ensuring it stays loyal to the source material despite not serving as either writer or showrunner.

The news comes as a shock because of its shamelessness. Does the Harry Potter series remain popular? Yes... to a point. Fans showed up for the wildly successful yet uneven Hogwarts Legacy but couldn't be less interested in the ridiculously misguided Fantastic Beasts saga. The reunion special on HBO Max worked for, like, a day but quickly disappeared from the conversation. And Harry Potter and the Cursed Child keeps packing them in on Broadway and London's West End, despite a mixed reception from fans. So yes, there's money in the Wizarding World, but unfortunately, Warner Bros. seems wholly unequipped to handle the IP because it doesn't understand why it worked in the first place.
Why Harry Potter worked in the first place

Entertainment

The Magic Flute director Florian Sigl on making a Harry Potter-esque fantasy

A boy looks up at a giant snake in The Magic Flute.

Most first-time directors take it a bit easy with their inaugural movies. Before he chronicled rampaging dinosaurs and killer sharks, Steven Spielberg made Duel, a simple movie about a man in a car being terrorized by a truck. Florian Sigl, however, isn't afraid to dive into the deep end of the moviemaking pool. The neophyte filmmaker has just made The Magic Flute, an adaptation of Mozart's famous opera that's also an epic, Harry Potter-esque fantasy involving lots of complicated CGI special effects.

In a conversation with Digital Trends, Sigl talks about why he wanted to adapt an opera as a big-budget fantasy film, how he felt lucky to cast Jack Wolfe before his breakout role in season 2 of Shadow and Bone, and the challenges involved in combining opera and a giant green snake on film.