Skip to main content

How HBO’s The Penguin sets the stage for The Batman Part 2 … and can make the sequel even better

Colin Farrell as Oz in promo art for HBO's The Penguin
HBO

Director Matt Reeves’ The Batman earned critical and commercial success in 2022, and while it’ll be sometime before the sequel, HBO’s The Penguin has been filling that void. Showrunner Lauren LeFranc (Chuck, Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) has done an impressive job of fleshing out the character arc of Colin Farrell’s transformative version of Oswald Cobblepot — and Gotham City with it.

The HBO miniseries feels like an ambitious Breaking Bad and Sopranos-like take on Batman’s sandbox, seemingly setting the stage for what fans might see in 2026’s The Batman Part II. While the show undoubtedly adds layers to “Oz’s” rise as a major player in the city’s streets, Cristin Milioti’s menacing Sofia Gigante suggests there’s more on the horizon for Gotham’s criminal underworld.

Recommended Videos

Note: The following article contains spoilers for HBO’s The Penguin.

The Kingpin of Gotham City

Oz attending a funeral in HBO's The Penguin.
HBO

Despite the limited screen time, Colin Farrell’s take on the Penguin was magnetic in Matt Reeves’ The Batman. His performance was transformative more than in the costuming sense, incredible as it was, as he injected some welcome dark humor and personality into one of Gotham City’s grimiest characters. While the initial announcement of the show’s existence might have baffled some audiences, The Penguin is another example of giving fans something they didn’t know they wanted. 

The Penguin doesn’t skip a beat in picking up where Oswald “Cobb” left off in The Batman. With seven of the miniseries’ eight episodes released, the plot gives meaningful insight into what the villain’s role might be in 2026’s The Batman Part II. Showrunner Lauren LeFranc’s series leans even more on the crime-noir atmosphere Reeves envisions for this Dark Knight’s universe, showing how Oz navigates the seedy machinations of Gotham City’s underworld. The Riddler’s devastating terrorist attack has turned the city into a free-for-all among its organized crime syndicates. But Oz’s brand of cunning seems to prove audiences are in for a Penguin with more power plays to make in The Batman Part II. As devilishly charismatic as Oz was in the 2022 film, the late Carmine Falcone and even Batman and Lt. James Gordon treated him like the butt of a joke. 

The Penguin - Opening Scene - Colin Farrel has crazy range!!

He’s far from it in HBO’s The Penguin, as he’s already elevated himself from underworld bottom-feeder to a bona fide mob boss. He’s revolutionized the drug trade with “Bliss,” striking at an incredibly vulnerable Gotham that can only barely distribute power across the city. It’s hard to believe the city will fully recover by the time The Batman Part II begins. This is reminiscent of the Batman comic book arc No Man’s Land, where a category 7.6 earthquake levels the city, and the government essentially declares it a lost cause.

It leads to the Caped Crusader’s rogues gallery wreaking even more havoc and carving out territories for themselves — a situation eerily similar to Matt Reeves’ universe. Oz has turned into an underground hit in Gotham’s crime scene literally and figuratively, and while fans eagerly anticipate how The Penguin’s final two episodes play out, he could easily be the city’s kingpin in the 2026 movie.

On the shoulders of Gigantes

Cristin Milioti wearing a fur coat as Sofia Gigante in The Penguin.
HBO

While HBO’ The Penguin has been a revolution for Oz’s place in the world, what’s even more impressive is Cristin Milioti’s portrayal of Sofia Gigante. The actress’s performance made Carmine Falcone’s daughter a relentless force of nature, overcoming years of torture in Arkham State Hospital after being framed as the “Hangman” serial killer and even usurping and disavowing her father’s side of the crime family. With Sofia even convincing Falcone’s rival Salvatore Maroni to join forces in a show of power, the Gigante boss could have a role to play beyond The Penguin.

With one episode in the HBO miniseries left, fans will need to wait for the dust to settle before getting a clearer picture of the state of organized crime going into The Batman Part II. However, it’s not unreasonable to think the Gigante crime family could be a major underworld player in the 2026 film, clashing with Oz’s new enterprise.

Sofia Falcone’s Villain Origin Story | The Penguin | Max

Sofia certainly has the willing foot soldiers and a powerful ally in Maroni to support that premise. That’s assuming, of course, she survives the events of The Penguin. Regardless, it’s an interesting change from the villain’s comic book counterpart in Dark Victory, where Sofia is revealed to be the Hangman killer out for revenge against Gotham P.D. figures associated with former District Attorney Harvey Dent (who eventually becomes Two-Face).

Gotham’s Dark Knight will have his hands full in 2026

Robert Pattinson as the Dark Knight in The Batman, investigating the Riddler's apartment.
Warner Bros. Pictures

Alternatively, Sofia Gigante could influence Gotham’s criminal state of play indirectly. Should Oz be the last one standing in the grisly conflicts to come, the newly-christened mob boss could absorb whatever resources the Gigante crime family leaves behind. This would see the Penguin fill the power vacuum left by Carmine Falcone in The Batman, with all other lesser crime families forced to play by his rules. Even so, it’s inevitable that The Batman Part II will feature a new major antagonist.

Matt Reeves has been touting his Batman canon as an epic crime saga, leaning on the more noir elements the hero is known for. LeFranc’s The Penguin emphasizes this further, opening the door for similarly-themed villains from Batman’s rogues gallery to enter the fray. While it would be more exciting to see antagonists with less live-action presence, Two-Face would seamlessly fit the tone and overarching narrative of The Batman universe.

Black Mask aims his gun in Birds of Prey.
Warner Bros.

With systemic corruption as a recurring theme, a once-promising DA falling from grace in Part II isn’t hard to believe. Even the famously brutal Roman Sionis, aka the “Black Mask,” could be introduced to challenge the underworld hierarchy through a rapidly growing Sionis Crime Family. Whichever new villainous direction Reeves decides to take in the sequel, the events of The Penguin and its shifting dynamics will pave the way for a new breed of organized crime for the Dark Knight to tackle in The Batman Part II.

New episodes of HBO’s The Penguin premiere on Sunday nights, and the first seven of eight episodes are available to stream now on Max. The Batman is also streaming, with Part II releasing in theaters on October 2, 2026.

Guillermo Kurten
Freelance Writer, Entertainment
A University of Houston graduate in Print Media Journalism, Guillermo has covered sports entertainment and practically all…
10 best episodes from Batman: The Animated Series on HBO Max
The shadowy silhouette of Batman standing atop a building in Gotham City.

The Batman has spread its wings and success over to HBO Max, opening up the movie to another segment of the general audience. The movie was a critical and commercial success, though the streaming platform has plenty of other solid Batman content available. In many ways, the early- to mid-'90s cartoon Batman: The Animated Series (BTAS) set the gold standard for how high the brooding superhero should be aiming for in any on-screen project.

BTAS perfectly balances the inherently whimsical nature of comic books with thought-provoking noir nuance. These episodes of The Animated Series, and by extension its sequel series, The New Batman Adventures (TNBA), are some of the best Dark Knight tales fans will find readily available.
Heart of Ice - BTAS

Read more
The Batman: Villains we could see in HBO’s Penguin spinoff
Split image of the Penguin overlooking Gotham in The Batman and the HBO Max logo.

The resounding success of Matt Reeves' The Batman is unquestionable at this point, with Robert Pattinson's take on DC Comics' brooding Dark Knight laying a promising foundation for the future. This blossoming Bat-verse is building a version of the superhero that draws on the "World's Greatest Detective" moniker from the comic book source material, and the world is already showing signs of its expanse. Even before getting to the talks of a prospective trilogy, HBO Max already has plans to branch out with the movie's supporting characters. The first to get the green light is The Penguin, with Colin Farrell confirmed to be returning to play the role of Oswald Cobblepot.

Farrell's portrayal of the classic Batman rogues 'gallery member was an impressive way of balancing a grounded, realistic take on the character with a look that's reminiscent of his comic book counterpart. Likewise, he was suitably conniving and even morbidly funny, which is unsurprising to anyone familiar with the actor's work in dark comedies like In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths. This version of the villain and the personality Farrell injects into him look promising for headlining a TV show of his own, and if the Scarface-like inspiration holds, it also opens the door for a variety of new villains to make their appearance.

Read more
The Batman’s deleted scene reveals Barry Keoghan’s Joker
A close-up shot of Barry Keoghan's Joker in The Batman.

Though Matt Reeves' The Batman ended with the city of Gotham forever changed, a small scene toward its conclusion hinted at the next foe Robert Pattinson's Batman will face. The Joker, an iconic villain throughout the Dark Knight's history, made an all too brief appearance near the film's end, when he chatted it up with Riddler before saying the two could be friends. However, a newl released deleted scene from the movie shows the Clown Prince of Crime, played by Barry Keoghan, conversing with the Bat behind bars in Arkham Asylum.

The Batman | Deleted Arkham Scene

Read more