Skip to main content

5 underrated movies on Netflix you need to watch in September 2024

Ryan Gosling looks up in First Man.
Universal

Netflix should rename September to “Crime Month” as several murder-focused stories hit the service in the coming weeks. The Perfect Couple, a murder mystery series starring Nicole Kidman, is now streaming. The other noteworthy series, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, arrives later this month and explores the homicidal brothers from the 1990s.

The Perfect Couple and Monsters will dominate the Netflix top 10. Many films in Netflix’s library might lose viewership because of these shows. That does not mean you should ignore them. Several movies listed below are underrated gems, including an entertaining heist from an auteur, a standout performance from an A-list star, and a cute coming-of-age romance.

Logan Lucky (2017)

Adam Driver sits on the couch as Channing Tatum stands over him in Logan Lucky.
Fingerprint Releasing

Do not take Steven Soderbergh for granted. The Oscar-winning filmmaker could have easily mailed it in after the Ocean’s trilogy and signed up for by-the-book jobs for paychecks. That’s not in Soderbergh’s DNA. Instead, the filmmaker has been making interesting genre pieces and experimenting with different camera techniques (High Flying Bird on an iPhone) for over a decade. How many directors would make a heist movie after Ocean’s Eleven? Not many!

Because Soderbergh is of a different breed, he made another heist movie in 2017 called Logan Lucky. Blue-collar worker Jimmy Logan (Channing Tatum) plans to rob the Charlotte Motor Speedway with the help of his one-armed brother Clyde (Adam Driver), sister Mellie (Riley Keough), and an incarcerated demolitions expert Joe Bang (Daniel Craig). Facing a hard deadline, the group must execute the heist during a crowded NASCAR race weekend. Per usual, Soderbergh delivers the goods with Logan Lucky, a crime caper you won’t soon forget.

Stream Logan Lucky on Netflix.

The Rundown (2003)

A man and a woman sit in a jungle in The Rundown.
Universal

Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson is a global megastar thanks to a popular wrestling persona and a successful transition to acting. Johnson has acted since 2001, when he appeared as The Scorpion King in The Mummy Returns. Since then, Johnson has made his bones in action, most notably Luke Hobbs in The Fast and the Furious franchise. Yet his best performance came early in his career. 2003, to be exact. That’s the year Johnson starred in Peter Berg’s The Rundown.

Johnson plays Beck, a no-nonsense bounty hunter who specializes in retrieving assets. Wanting out of the bounty business, Beck takes one last job for his boss, Billy Walker (William Lucking). The mission: to find Walker’s son, Travis (Seann William Scott), who was last seen in Brazil. Beck finds Travis, but the duo can’t escape from the town’s tyrant and treasure hunter (Christopher Walken). No movie has used Johnson’s physicality and comedic instincts better than The Rundown.

Stream The Rundown on Netflix.

First Man (2018)

A group of astronauts turn to the side and pose.
Universal Pictures

Coming off Whiplash and La La Land, Damien Chazelle could have made any movie he wanted. Whiplash, an edge-of-your-seat drama, and La La Land, a romantic musical, are loud, stylish, and fast-moving. Yet Chazelle did a complete 180 for his next film, First Man, a biopic about Neil Armstrong with Ryan Gosling playing the famous astronaut.

First Man depicts Armstrong’s time at NASA during the Space Race of the 1960s. Armstrong made his bones as a test pilot, narrowly avoiding death on multiple occasions. In 1969, Armstrong became the first man to walk on the moon. While First Man‘s lunar landing is stunning, the film is more concerned with Armstrong, the person, who was full of grief and sadness. First Man is quiet, stoic, and hauntingly beautiful.

Stream First Man on Netflix.

My Girl 2 (1994)

A young boy and girl sit next to each other on a bench.
Columbia Pictures

My Girl is a charming coming-of-age romance about Vada (Anna Chlumsky), a curious 11-year-old girl who comes of age while learning about love, death, and grief. My Girl 2 is both financially and critically inferior to My Girl. That’s not up for debate. However, upon further review, My Girl 2 still has enough delightful moments that make it worthy of a rewatch.

In the sequel, Vada is now a 13-year-old teenager who receives a school assignment to write about someone she admires but has never met. Vada chooses her late mother, who died two days after childbirth. With permission from her father (Dan Aykroyd), Vada goes to Los Angeles during spring break to stay with her uncle Phil (Richard Masur) and learn more about her mother. While she yearns for answers, Vada’s love life gets an unexpected boost from Nick (Austin O’Brien), Phil’s girlfriend’s son.

Stream My Girl 2 on Netflix.

I Care A Lot (2020)

Rosamund Pike holds a cup of coffee in front of a wall of photos.
Netflix

Rosamund Pike thrives when she’s playing the villain. The Oscar nominee was downright spectacular as the deceitful Amy Elliott Dunne in David Fincher’s Gone Girl. Pike channeled her sadistic side again in I Care A Lot. Con artist Marla Grayson is despicable; there is no way around it. She convinces the legal system to grant her guardianship over elders after making it seem like they can’t care for themselves.

Marla then proceeds to force the courts to put these elders in an assisted care facility while she sells their homes for profit. When Marla sends the mother of a crime lord to a nursing home, the mafia takes matters into their own hands and fights back. Frankly, I Care A Lot will agitate a lot of viewers. However, Pike’s performance is so over-the-top and magnetic that you can’t look away.

Stream I Care A Lot on Netflix.

Dan Girolamo
Dan is a passionate and multitalented content creator with experience in pop culture, entertainment, and sports. Throughout…
3 rom-coms on Netflix you need to watch in September 2024
A woman holds onto a man's shoulder as they walk.

The summer movie season has ended on Netflix. The streamer released several high-profile romance films over the last few months. Hit Man, Richard Linklater's latest film starring Glen Powell as a fake gun-for-hire, and A Family Affair, a rom-com with Nicole Kidman and Zac Efron, were both two of the most popular Netflix movies of the summer.

Just because the season changes doesn't mean rom-coms have to stop. Netflix offers hundreds of romantic comedies for subscribers to stream right now. This September, watch these three rom-coms on Netflix: a Ben Stiller comedy, a high school dance film, and a teen romance.
Along Came Polly (2004)

Read more
The best free movies on YouTube right now (September 2024)
Daniel Day-Lewis sits down and stares.

Streaming services provide thousands of movies for consumers to watch every month. Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video, and Max are some of the top streaming services on the market. However, these services have monthly fees. If you subscribe to all four services, then it will cost you a pretty penny. If you're looking for alternative streaming options, try YouTube, which offers free movies with ads.

YouTube is not a typical streaming service with thousands of movies in its library. However, don't sleep on YouTube. There are plenty of popular films in multiple genres available to stream immediately. To help influence your selections, we curated a list of the best free movies to watch on YouTube this month.
Looking for more stuff you can watch for free? Check out our guides to the best free shows on YouTube and the best sites for watching free movies online.

Read more
5 great Netflix movies to watch on Labor Day
A soldier runs through a battlefield in "Hacksaw Ridge."

Take time this Labor Day weekend to relax and catch up on some movies on Netflix. Several new Netflix originals, like Terminator Zero and Kaos, have been released this past week. In the film section, The Union, a spy comedy with Mark Wahlberg and Halle Berry, and Migration, an animated adventure from Illumination, are two of the most popular movies on Netflix.

Speaking of movies, Netflix's film vault is unprecedented, with hundreds of choices within each genre. Do you need a movie to watch this Labor Day weekend? Well, you've come to the right place. Our five picks include a scandalous sports documentary, a coming-of-age tale set at a high school party, and a cute romance.

Read more