Skip to main content

That indicator of life on Venus may just have been sulfur dioxide

An image of Venus compiled using data from the Mariner 10 spacecraft in 1974
An image of Venus compiled using data from the Mariner 10 spacecraft in 1974 NASA/JPL-Caltech

Last September, the astronomical community was shaken by research that indicated there could be signs of life on Venus. The researchers found indicators of a gas called phosphine in the Venusian atmosphere, which as far as we know is produced only by anaerobic (non-oxygen-reliant) bacteria.

Since then, scientists have debated back and forth about this finding and whether it was reliable. Now, a new study suggests that the gas which was detected was not phosphine but was in fact sulfur dioxide, a much more common gas with no special relation to life.

Recommended Videos

The new study by researchers at the University of Washington used a computer model of the atmospheric conditions of Venus to understand what could have given off the signal which was thought to be phosphine. They think there is a more prosaic explanation for the readings.

“Instead of phosphine in the clouds of Venus, the data are consistent with an alternative hypothesis: They were detecting sulfur dioxide,” said co-author Victoria Meadows, a UW professor of astronomy, in a statement. “Sulfur dioxide is the third-most-common chemical compound in Venus’ atmosphere, and it is not considered a sign of life.”

The team also says that the signal coming from sulfur dioxide is more consistent with what we know about the environment of Venus than phosphine would be. The surface of Venus is hidden beneath dense clouds of sulfuric acid, with an atmosphere that is whipped around by high wind speeds.

The difficulty in working out whether there really is phosphine in the atmosphere comes from the methods used to examine the planet. As we can’t collect a sample of the Venusian atmosphere directly, researchers use radio telescopes to look at the planet. These radio telescopes show absorption in the radio waves at a particular wavelength — 266.94 gigahertz — which is around the frequency absorbed by both phosphine and sulfur dioxide. It’s difficult to tell which of the chemicals is causing the absorption, which is why there have been debates and a number of studies since trying to pick apart this puzzle.

This new finding doesn’t definitely disprove the hypothesis of phosphine on Venus, but it does make it seem less likely. We’ll have to wait for more debate and more data for a final answer on our mysterious planetary neighbor and the possibility of life there.

Georgina Torbet
Georgina has been the space writer at Digital Trends space writer for six years, covering human space exploration, planetary…
Water could have been on Mars more recently than we thought
NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter used its Context Camera to capture this image of Bosporos Planum, a location on Mars. The white specks are salt deposits found within a dry channel. The largest impact crater in the scene is nearly 1 mile (1.5 kilometers) across.

One of the biggest topics in Mars research right now is understanding the history of water on the planet. Scientists know that there was once abundant liquid water on its surface, though now all that water has disappeared and the planet is arid. The only remaining water on Mars's surface today is in the form of water ice near its poles or in deep canyons. To understand what happened to all the water which was present billions of years ago, researchers are trying to piece together a geological history of the planet.

Most researchers thought that the water on Mars evaporated around 3 billion years ago, but new research is questioning this figure. Recent data from NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) suggests that there could have been water on Mars as recently as 2 billion years ago, meaning we may have to re-configure our understanding of the planet's history.

Read more
MIT researchers detail plans for private missions to search for life on Venus
Caption: A false-color image of the sulfurous Venusian cloud cover was produced using two ultraviolet channels from Akatsuki, the Japanese PLANET-C, and Venus Climate Orbiter, which highlights the convective turbulence of the planet's tropical regions, in contrast with the clear, smoother polar regions.

A suite of new privately-funded missions will be heading to Venus to search our neighboring planet for signs of life. In a recently released report, researchers from MIT have detailed more about their plans for the Venus Life Finder (VLF) missions.

A false-color image of the sulfurous Venusian cloud cover. Daimia Bouic/JAXA/ISAS/DARTS

Read more
NASA video shows you what it’s like to plunge through Venus’ atmosphere
nasa video davinci venus

NASA is planning its first robotic explorers to Venus in over 30 years, with the announcement this summer of the DAVINCI+ and VERITAS missions. Now, NASA has shown what one of those missions will be facing with the release of a video visualization of the DAVINCI probe plunging through the Venusian atmosphere.

The DAVINCI Mission to Venus

Read more